<html>
<head>
<meta http-equiv="content-type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8">
</head>
<body>
<div>Note that Import Guidelines required discussion and documenting import<br></div><div>also then: <a href="https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/w/index.php?title=Import/Guidelines&oldid=211128">https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/w/index.php?title=Import/Guidelines&oldid=211128</a><br></div><div>(this link to state of that of page at time of making that edit)<br></div><div><br></div><div>If import was not discussed it is OK to remove whatever it added (though, after 12 years<br></div><div>an automated revert may not be feasible).<br></div><div><br></div><div>BTW, large parts of that were deleted already 3 and 5 years ago with changeset<br></div><div>comments mentioning low data quality.<br></div><div><br></div><div>Feb 16, 2021, 01:24 by m@rtijn.org:<br></div><blockquote class="tutanota_quote" style="border-left: 1px solid #93A3B8; padding-left: 10px; margin-left: 5px;"><p>Hi all.<br></p><p>While cleaning up some TIGER data in Georgia, I came across a
number of land use polygons that seem to have resulted from a USGS
import that looks to have happened about 12 years ago. Here is one
of the changesets: <a href="https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/660316" class="" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/660316</a><br></p><p>There is a reference to this import on the Georgia wiki page: <a href="https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Georgia_(U.S._state)#Land_Use" class="" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Georgia_(U.S._state)#Land_Use</a> . The user (Liber) does not seem to be active any longer, but I
haven't contacted them yet.<br></p><p>This Overpass query suggests that there are almost 4000 ways with
the identifying source tags: <a href="https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/13xi" class="" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/13xi</a> .
Many of the examples I came across are of dubious quality. Either
there is little relation to ground truth, deprecated tagging is
used, or both.<br></p><div>I raised this in #local-georgia on Slack, but local mappers there
are not familiar with the import.I created a MapRoulette Challenge
to look at these one-by-one, but the community may prefer a
different approach?<a href="https://maproulette.org/browse/challenges/16952" class="" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://maproulette.org/browse/challenges/16952</a><span style="border-block: unset; border-inline: unset; border-start-start-radius: unset; border-start-end-radius: unset; border-end-start-radius: unset; border-end-end-radius: unset; overflow-inline: unset; overflow-block: unset; overscroll-behavior-inline: unset; overscroll-behavior-block: unset; margin-block: unset; margin-inline: unset; scroll-margin-block: unset; scroll-margin-inline: unset; padding-block: unset; padding-inline: unset; scroll-padding-block: unset; scroll-padding-inline: unset; inset-block: unset; inset-inline: unset; block-size: unset; min-block-size: unset; max-block-size: unset; inline-size: unset; min-inline-size: unset; max-inline-size: unset; background: unset; background-blend-mode: unset; border: unset; border-radius: unset; box-decoration-break: unset; -moz-float-edge: unset; display: unset; float: unset; clear: unset; vertical-align: unset; overflow: unset; overflow-anchor: unset; transition: unset; animation: unset; transform: unset; rotate: unset; scale: unset; translate: unset; offset: unset; scroll-behavior: unset; scroll-snap-align: unset; scroll-snap-type: unset; overscroll-behavior: unset; isolation: unset; break-after: unset; break-before: unset; break-inside: unset; resize: unset; perspective: unset; perspective-origin: unset; backface-visibility: unset; transform-box: unset; transform-style: unset; transform-origin: unset; contain: unset; appearance: unset; -moz-orient: unset; will-change: unset; shape-image-threshold: unset; shape-margin: unset; shape-outside: unset; touch-action: unset; -webkit-line-clamp: unset; columns: unset; column-fill: unset; column-rule: unset; column-span: unset; content: unset; counter-increment: unset; counter-reset: unset; counter-set: unset; opacity: unset; box-shadow: unset; clip: rect(0px, 0px, 0px, 0px); filter: unset; mix-blend-mode: unset; font-style: unset; font-variant: unset; font-weight: unset; font-stretch: unset; line-height: unset; font-size-adjust: unset; font-kerning: unset; font-optical-sizing: unset; font-language-override: unset; font-feature-settings: unset; font-variation-settings: unset; font-synthesis: unset; visibility: unset; writing-mode: unset; text-orientation: unset; color-adjust: unset; image-rendering: unset; image-orientation: unset; dominant-baseline: unset; text-anchor: unset; color-interpolation: unset; color-interpolation-filters: unset; fill: unset; fill-opacity: unset; fill-rule: unset; shape-rendering: unset; stroke: unset; stroke-width: unset; stroke-linecap: unset; stroke-linejoin: unset; stroke-miterlimit: unset; stroke-opacity: unset; stroke-dasharray: unset; stroke-dashoffset: unset; clip-rule: unset; marker: unset; paint-order: unset; -moz-context-properties: unset; border-collapse: unset; empty-cells: unset; caption-side: unset; border-spacing: unset; color: unset; text-transform: unset; hyphens: unset; -moz-text-size-adjust: unset; text-indent: unset; overflow-wrap: unset; word-break: unset; text-justify: unset; text-align-last: unset; text-align: unset; letter-spacing: unset; word-spacing: unset; white-space: pre; text-shadow: unset; text-emphasis: unset; text-emphasis-position: unset; -moz-tab-size: unset; line-break: unset; -webkit-text-fill-color: unset; -webkit-text-stroke: unset; ruby-align: unset; ruby-position: unset; text-combine-upright: unset; text-rendering: unset; -moz-control-character-visibility: unset; text-underline-offset: unset; text-underline-position: unset; text-decoration-skip-ink: unset; cursor: unset; pointer-events: unset; -moz-user-input: unset; -moz-user-modify: unset; -moz-user-focus: unset; caret-color: unset; scrollbar-color: unset; list-style: unset; quotes: unset; -moz-image-region: unset; margin: unset; scroll-margin: unset; outline: unset; -moz-outline-radius: unset; outline-offset: unset; padding: unset; scroll-padding: unset; top: 0px; right: unset; bottom: unset; left: unset; z-index: unset; flex-flow: unset; place-content: unset; place-items: unset; flex: unset; place-self: unset; order: unset; width: unset; min-width: unset; max-width: unset; height: unset; min-height: unset; max-height: unset; box-sizing: unset; object-fit: unset; object-position: unset; grid-area: unset; grid: unset; gap: unset; vector-effect: unset; stop-color: unset; stop-opacity: unset; flood-color: unset; flood-opacity: unset; lighting-color: unset; mask-type: unset; clip-path: unset; mask: unset; x: unset; y: unset; cx: unset; cy: unset; rx: unset; ry: unset; r: unset; table-layout: unset; text-overflow: unset; text-decoration: unset; ime-mode: unset; scrollbar-width: unset; user-select: text; -moz-window-dragging: unset; -moz-force-broken-image-icon: unset; -moz-box-align: unset; -moz-box-direction: unset; -moz-box-flex: unset; -moz-box-orient: unset; -moz-box-pack: unset; -moz-box-ordinal-group: unset;"><span class="font" style="font-family:unset"><span class="size" style="font-size:unset"><a href="https://maproulette.org/browse/challenges/16952" class="" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://maproulette.org/browse/challenges/16952</a></span></span></span><span style="border-block: unset; border-inline: unset; border-start-start-radius: unset; border-start-end-radius: unset; border-end-start-radius: unset; border-end-end-radius: unset; overflow-inline: unset; overflow-block: unset; overscroll-behavior-inline: unset; overscroll-behavior-block: unset; margin-block: unset; margin-inline: unset; scroll-margin-block: unset; scroll-margin-inline: unset; padding-block: unset; padding-inline: unset; scroll-padding-block: unset; scroll-padding-inline: unset; inset-block: unset; inset-inline: unset; block-size: unset; min-block-size: unset; max-block-size: unset; inline-size: unset; min-inline-size: unset; max-inline-size: unset; background: unset; background-blend-mode: unset; border: unset; border-radius: unset; box-decoration-break: unset; -moz-float-edge: unset; display: unset; float: unset; clear: unset; vertical-align: unset; overflow: unset; overflow-anchor: unset; transition: unset; animation: unset; transform: unset; rotate: unset; scale: unset; translate: unset; offset: unset; scroll-behavior: unset; scroll-snap-align: unset; scroll-snap-type: unset; overscroll-behavior: unset; isolation: unset; break-after: unset; break-before: unset; break-inside: unset; resize: unset; perspective: unset; perspective-origin: unset; backface-visibility: unset; transform-box: unset; transform-style: unset; transform-origin: unset; contain: unset; appearance: unset; -moz-orient: unset; will-change: unset; shape-image-threshold: unset; shape-margin: unset; shape-outside: unset; touch-action: unset; -webkit-line-clamp: unset; columns: unset; column-fill: unset; column-rule: unset; column-span: unset; content: unset; counter-increment: unset; counter-reset: unset; counter-set: unset; opacity: unset; box-shadow: unset; clip: rect(0px, 0px, 0px, 0px); filter: unset; mix-blend-mode: unset; font-style: unset; font-variant: unset; font-weight: unset; font-stretch: unset; line-height: unset; font-size-adjust: unset; font-kerning: unset; font-optical-sizing: unset; font-language-override: unset; font-feature-settings: unset; font-variation-settings: unset; font-synthesis: unset; visibility: unset; writing-mode: unset; text-orientation: unset; color-adjust: unset; image-rendering: unset; image-orientation: unset; dominant-baseline: unset; text-anchor: unset; color-interpolation: unset; color-interpolation-filters: unset; fill: unset; fill-opacity: unset; fill-rule: unset; shape-rendering: unset; stroke: unset; stroke-width: unset; stroke-linecap: unset; stroke-linejoin: unset; stroke-miterlimit: unset; stroke-opacity: unset; stroke-dasharray: unset; stroke-dashoffset: unset; clip-rule: unset; marker: unset; paint-order: unset; -moz-context-properties: unset; border-collapse: unset; empty-cells: unset; caption-side: unset; border-spacing: unset; color: unset; text-transform: unset; hyphens: unset; -moz-text-size-adjust: unset; text-indent: unset; overflow-wrap: unset; word-break: unset; text-justify: unset; text-align-last: unset; text-align: unset; letter-spacing: unset; word-spacing: unset; white-space: pre; text-shadow: unset; text-emphasis: unset; text-emphasis-position: unset; -moz-tab-size: unset; line-break: unset; -webkit-text-fill-color: unset; -webkit-text-stroke: unset; ruby-align: unset; ruby-position: unset; text-combine-upright: unset; text-rendering: unset; -moz-control-character-visibility: unset; text-underline-offset: unset; text-underline-position: unset; text-decoration-skip-ink: unset; cursor: unset; pointer-events: unset; -moz-user-input: unset; -moz-user-modify: unset; -moz-user-focus: unset; caret-color: unset; scrollbar-color: unset; list-style: unset; quotes: unset; -moz-image-region: unset; margin: unset; scroll-margin: unset; outline: unset; -moz-outline-radius: unset; outline-offset: unset; padding: unset; scroll-padding: unset; top: 0px; right: unset; bottom: unset; left: unset; z-index: unset; flex-flow: unset; place-content: unset; place-items: unset; flex: unset; place-self: unset; order: unset; width: unset; min-width: unset; max-width: unset; height: unset; min-height: unset; max-height: unset; box-sizing: unset; object-fit: unset; object-position: unset; grid-area: unset; grid: unset; gap: unset; vector-effect: unset; stop-color: unset; stop-opacity: unset; flood-color: unset; flood-opacity: unset; lighting-color: unset; mask-type: unset; clip-path: unset; mask: unset; x: unset; y: unset; cx: unset; cy: unset; rx: unset; ry: unset; r: unset; table-layout: unset; text-overflow: unset; text-decoration: unset; ime-mode: unset; scrollbar-width: unset; user-select: text; -moz-window-dragging: unset; -moz-force-broken-image-icon: unset; -moz-box-align: unset; -moz-box-direction: unset; -moz-box-flex: unset; -moz-box-orient: unset; -moz-box-pack: unset; -moz-box-ordinal-group: unset;"><span class="font" style="font-family:unset"><span class="size" style="font-size:unset"><a href="https://maproulette.org/browse/challenges/1695" class="" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://maproulette.org/browse/challenges/1695</a></span></span></span>.
What are your thoughts on how to proceed?<br></div><div> <br></div><p><span style="border-block: unset; border-inline: unset; border-start-start-radius: unset; border-start-end-radius: unset; border-end-start-radius: unset; border-end-end-radius: unset; overflow-inline: unset; overflow-block: unset; overscroll-behavior-inline: unset; overscroll-behavior-block: unset; margin-block: unset; margin-inline: unset; scroll-margin-block: unset; scroll-margin-inline: unset; padding-block: unset; padding-inline: unset; scroll-padding-block: unset; scroll-padding-inline: unset; inset-block: unset; inset-inline: unset; block-size: unset; min-block-size: unset; max-block-size: unset; inline-size: unset; min-inline-size: unset; max-inline-size: unset; background: unset; background-blend-mode: unset; border: unset; border-radius: unset; box-decoration-break: unset; -moz-float-edge: unset; display: unset; float: unset; clear: unset; vertical-align: unset; overflow: unset; overflow-anchor: unset; transition: unset; animation: unset; transform: unset; rotate: unset; scale: unset; translate: unset; offset: unset; scroll-behavior: unset; scroll-snap-align: unset; scroll-snap-type: unset; overscroll-behavior: unset; isolation: unset; break-after: unset; break-before: unset; break-inside: unset; resize: unset; perspective: unset; perspective-origin: unset; backface-visibility: unset; transform-box: unset; transform-style: unset; transform-origin: unset; contain: unset; appearance: unset; -moz-orient: unset; will-change: unset; shape-image-threshold: unset; shape-margin: unset; shape-outside: unset; touch-action: unset; -webkit-line-clamp: unset; columns: unset; column-fill: unset; column-rule: unset; column-span: unset; content: unset; counter-increment: unset; counter-reset: unset; counter-set: unset; opacity: unset; box-shadow: unset; clip: rect(0px, 0px, 0px, 0px); filter: unset; mix-blend-mode: unset; font-style: unset; font-variant: unset; font-weight: unset; font-stretch: unset; line-height: unset; font-size-adjust: unset; font-kerning: unset; font-optical-sizing: unset; font-language-override: unset; font-feature-settings: unset; font-variation-settings: unset; font-synthesis: unset; visibility: unset; writing-mode: unset; text-orientation: unset; color-adjust: unset; image-rendering: unset; image-orientation: unset; dominant-baseline: unset; text-anchor: unset; color-interpolation: unset; color-interpolation-filters: unset; fill: unset; fill-opacity: unset; fill-rule: unset; shape-rendering: unset; stroke: unset; stroke-width: unset; stroke-linecap: unset; stroke-linejoin: unset; stroke-miterlimit: unset; stroke-opacity: unset; stroke-dasharray: unset; stroke-dashoffset: unset; clip-rule: unset; marker: unset; paint-order: unset; -moz-context-properties: unset; border-collapse: unset; empty-cells: unset; caption-side: unset; border-spacing: unset; color: unset; text-transform: unset; hyphens: unset; -moz-text-size-adjust: unset; text-indent: unset; overflow-wrap: unset; word-break: unset; text-justify: unset; text-align-last: unset; text-align: unset; letter-spacing: unset; word-spacing: unset; white-space: pre; text-shadow: unset; text-emphasis: unset; text-emphasis-position: unset; -moz-tab-size: unset; line-break: unset; -webkit-text-fill-color: unset; -webkit-text-stroke: unset; ruby-align: unset; ruby-position: unset; text-combine-upright: unset; text-rendering: unset; -moz-control-character-visibility: unset; text-underline-offset: unset; text-underline-position: unset; text-decoration-skip-ink: unset; cursor: unset; pointer-events: unset; -moz-user-input: unset; -moz-user-modify: unset; -moz-user-focus: unset; caret-color: unset; scrollbar-color: unset; list-style: unset; quotes: unset; -moz-image-region: unset; margin: unset; scroll-margin: unset; outline: unset; -moz-outline-radius: unset; outline-offset: unset; padding: unset; scroll-padding: unset; top: 0px; right: unset; bottom: unset; left: unset; z-index: unset; flex-flow: unset; place-content: unset; place-items: unset; flex: unset; place-self: unset; order: unset; width: unset; min-width: unset; max-width: unset; height: unset; min-height: unset; max-height: unset; box-sizing: unset; object-fit: unset; object-position: unset; grid-area: unset; grid: unset; gap: unset; vector-effect: unset; stop-color: unset; stop-opacity: unset; flood-color: unset; flood-opacity: unset; lighting-color: unset; mask-type: unset; clip-path: unset; mask: unset; x: unset; y: unset; cx: unset; cy: unset; rx: unset; ry: unset; r: unset; table-layout: unset; text-overflow: unset; text-decoration: unset; ime-mode: unset; scrollbar-width: unset; user-select: text; -moz-window-dragging: unset; -moz-force-broken-image-icon: unset; -moz-box-align: unset; -moz-box-direction: unset; -moz-box-flex: unset; -moz-box-orient: unset; -moz-box-pack: unset; -moz-box-ordinal-group: unset;"><span class="font" style="font-family:unset"><span class="size" style="font-size:unset">2</span></span></span><br></p><div>Martijn<br></div><div> <br></div><p><br></p></blockquote><div><br></div> </body>
</html>