[OSM-dev] [OSM-talk] Map key on osm.org
wendorff at uni-paderborn.de
Thu Mar 22 14:45:37 GMT 2012
Preface: I'll copy this mail to the dev at openstreetmap.org list, too, so
please restrict to one list when answering; but I think, this mail deals
with dev-issues, too and parts of the discussion might progress better
I don't see the English descriptions, so I hope to guess the right keys
Most issues I list here are missing or obsolete items. Errors (where the
map key and the map differ) are marked as ERROR! if you only want to
deal with these.
German descriptions in paratheses.
I checked everything up to zoom level 10, afterwards it's difficult as
both, map and key get more crowded. So in higher zoom levels I restrict
to errors and issues I see by accident.
Btw: What about generating the map key from the stylesheet
automatically? Is there any ongoing work on that?
level 0: renders only land and water, but map key contains motorway
(Autobahn), trunk (Schnellstraße) and Country? These are not shown up to
level 4. borders (Landesgrenzen, sonstige Grenzen)
level 1: similar to 0, borders are shown, the other two are "obsolete"
in the map key
level 2, 3: missing key for Country labels
level 4: no differentiation between the two, but different border types
(countries vs. states)
level 5: missing key for Capitals
level 6: glaciers are missing (but quite prominent e.g. in the Alps).
Meaning of the city label changes (compared to lvl5): includes
additional big cities.
level 7: national parks are missing, but rendered (light green)
level 8: map shows forests/woods (very prominent), but that's not in the
level 9: missing key for agricultural landuse (Landwirtschaft in level
10), but prominent in many areas. Rivers missing
level 10: Motorway key should contain the shield (as common in
"commercial" maps), Airports are missing, restricted areas are missing
(the red, diagonal striped areas)
level 11: trunks and primary roads are rendered with shields in the map,
should be reflected in the map key; motorway links are rendered as small
numbers, but not in the map key. Peaks are missing in the map key;
nature reserve(?) (rendered as small green NR "icons" on areas) is
missing in the map key
level 13: tertiary is missing in the map key
well... on a deeper look the "error" I saw is no error (secondary and
tertiary are similar, and I interpreted the secondary map key for a
street that was a tertiary in the map, while in that area no secondary
Nevertheless: Anything that counts against generating the map key in
general out of the stylesheet?
If that would be possible, we could additionally support the
opencyclemap, public transport map (afaik both rendered with mapnik,
too) and probably even Mapquest, if they support this.
Is there any development on
Probably that is a good starting point for automatic generation of the
Am 22.03.2012 14:42, schrieb Steve Chilton:
> I produced the images (ages ago).
> If there are anomalies in the colours or symbols please let me know as I can change them.
> They are deliberately a subset of all the possible entities that could be included.
> Steve Chilton, Learning Support Fellow
> Educational Development Manager
> Centre for Learning and Teaching Enhancement
> Middlesex University
> phone: 020 8411 5355
> email: steve8 at mdx.ac.uk
> Profile: http://www.middlesex.wikispaces.net/user/view/steve8
> Chair of the Society of Cartographers: http://www.soc.org.uk/
> Chair of ICA Neocartography Commission: http://www.soc.org.uk/neocartography/
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Tom Hughes [mailto:tom at compton.nu]
> Sent: 22 March 2012 13:37
> To: Peter Wendorff
> Cc: talk at openstreetmap.org
> Subject: Re: [OSM-talk] Map key on osm.org
> On 22/03/12 13:23, Peter Wendorff wrote:
>> How is the map key (german: Legende) generated on osm.org?
>> It looks like it is out of sync for the mapnik rendering (viewing from
>> Germany, description texts are in german).
>> - some items are not matching between map key and map
>> - many items rendered in the map are not reflected in the map key
>> Has this e.g. to be generated for an updated mapnik stylesheet?
> It's completely manual - at some point somebody gave me a load of images
> and text and I build a key from them.
More information about the dev