[Imports] Attribution of CORINE and Urban Atlas imports
Frederik Ramm
frederik at remote.org
Wed Apr 6 20:27:54 UTC 2011
Hi,
at a conference today I met someone who works for EEA in Copenhagen
and we had a chat about EEA data in OSM. A very friendly chat, I must
add, he wasn't actually complaining about anything, but he did mention a
few oddities he found when studying how OSM was using CORINE (and Urban
Atlas) data.
I'm listing them here in the hope that maybe some of them can be
rectified, or avoided in future CORINE imports (hello Dermot!)
a) Corine Land Cover
Generally, you can obtain CORINE data from national bodies or from the
EEA directly. The data sets may be minimally different, and may be
licensed differently.
The French import states as their source: "Union européenne - SOeS,
CORINE Land Cover, 2006.", where SoeS stands for "le service de
l'Observation et des Statistiques (SOeS) du Commissariat général au
développement durable (CGDD)". This is a French national organisation.
The Romanian import took their data directly from the EEA (as documented
on http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/CLC_RO_Permission), but in their
source tags they credit SOeS like the French did which is not correct.
It would be great if this could be fixed, or at least rectified on the
wiki page.
There's also a Spanish, Estonian, and Hungarian CORINE import of which I
haven't fully investigated the tags. For Hungary,
http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Catalog mentions both the
national office and the EEA as their source which is porbably not
correct either.
b) Urban Atlas
There's a lot of Urban Atlas-sourced material in OSM was well, most of
it in Poland or Slovakia. Some of it is tagged only with "source=urban
atlas" but there's no mention of the EEA. Much like ourselves, the EEA
would prefer to be credited properly if their data is used.
As I said, it's not that EEA are complaining (and they don't have any
set-in-stone attribution rules anyway, only that you have to attribute)
but we should certainly aim to do it right!
Bye
Frederik
--
Frederik Ramm ## eMail frederik at remote.org ## N49°00'09" E008°23'33"
More information about the Imports
mailing list