Tools to tag bridges/culverts at road-waterstream crossings

Grigory Rechistov ggg_mail at inbox.ru
Sat Feb 10 11:03:01 UTC 2018


Hello JOSM-dev,

As I use JOSM to map mostly rural areas of the Earth, I often draw minor roads (tertiary, unclassified, tracks) and minor water streams (tiny rivers and streams). Naturally, they often cross each other. During validation checks before committing changes, I always face with the warning that such crossings should have a bridge and/or a culvert marked. The problem is, it is disproportionally hard to add bridges compared to drawing continuous lines: I have to split just drawn water stream in two points, then select its middle part going under the road, and finally assign a tag to it. And then to repeat almost identical split-select-tag process for the new road.

This workflow interrupts the drawing process and slows me down a lot. Given that not drawing small bridges is only a warning, I find myself often tempted to ignore it and commit things as is, and not to distract myself. My question is: what are ideas to help me and others in such situation?

Solutions that I can see:
1. Do not consider crossings of minor roads with minor streams as a warning during validation. 
2. Add a resolution choice into validation window  that splits and assigns proper tags to road /water sections. The warning is still shown so that it is the person who decides in each case. 
3. Add a tool that does the work when pointed to a road/stream crossing. This leaves more control to user, however I estimate it to be more complex to implement. 

Or maybe there is already a similar functionality that can be quickly adapted to my needs? 

С наилучшими пожеланиями,
Григорий Речистов.
Best regards,
Grigory Rechistov


More information about the josm-dev mailing list