[OSM-newbies] Secondary vs tertiary roads

Stephen Wing stephen at wintoncourt.co.uk
Tue Aug 7 19:26:20 BST 2007


Richard Endersby wrote:
> I'm preparing to do some mapping and to fill in some gaps in the minor 
> road network in mid bedofrdshire (UK) 

I've updated one or two roads as best I understand it (*) in that rough 
area too, as it's close to home.  I'm planning to get another GPS for 
mapping the area at some point, but feel free to add in lots of detail 
to save me the effort :)  I'm fairly new to OSM, hence I've started out 
by just editing my local data, although I'm using both potlatch and JOSM.

(*) ie how I understand I should use the various settings - my data is 
based on driving / walking and reading the road signs, as opposed to me 
guessing the data.

According to the wiki the UK settings for "highway" are as follows, 
trunk is the primary trunk route, primary is the remaining A roads, 
secondary is B roads, but what about a non-B road that more than just a 
residential road, as it goes somewhere, but has houses on it - should it 
be residential, or unclassified, or tertiary (not mentioned in the wiki)...?

eg Station Road from Henlow Camp towards Lower Stondon (shown as Upper 
Stondon) on the map is a road that goes somewhere (Shillington, and onto 
Barton-le-Clay (shown as Barton in the Clay) once the data gets added / 
edited, but is neither an A, nor B road (according to the roadsigns)...

Some of the roads East of this area towards Stotfold, which has been 
well mapped are listed as tertiary, which would seem correct, although I 
note that Potlatch does not have a preset of tertiary, which seems strange.

So, I guess a non-B road that goes somewhere, and many of the roads in 
Richard's URL (covering Shefford) should be re-classified as tertiary if 
I understand things correctly (and the setting I've used for Station 
Road - the update should hit tonight / tomorrow)...

Here's another question - should a roundabout (with junction=roundabout 
set) also have oneway=yes set?  In that same area, some roundabouts have 
oneway=set, and some don't - what criteria should be used for choosing 
whether or not to set "oneway"?

Thanks,

Steve




More information about the newbies mailing list