[Tagging] area=yes on polygones (was Block names)

Tobias Knerr osm at tobias-knerr.de
Sat Apr 28 14:16:49 BST 2012


On 27.04.2012 10:12, Pieren wrote:
> You have to know anyway if your feature can be either a closed way or
> an area and therefore need some special handling in your apps.

Unfortunately, yes. I wish we already had a proper area primitive so
this whole discussion would be obsolete.

> The question is then more to consider certain features as "area" or
> "closed way" by default. On this point, I'm always standing on the
> contributors side and wont ask them to add an unnecessary tag for
> 99.99% of the cases.

Having to type "area=yes" less frequently is in the contributors'
interest, sure. But having simple rules for defaults is also in the
contributors' interest.

Right now, we already have to distinguish three types of tags:
* always area
* always way
* way unless area=yes is present.

I simply do not think that the possibility to decrease of the number of
tags is worth introducing "area unless area=no is present" in addition
to these. Particularly because whether area or way is the default would
depend on what is assumed to be more likely in reality. And people might
easily have different assumptions here, making that kind of default
non-obvious.

Tobias



More information about the Tagging mailing list