[Tagging] Artworks inside the Louvre

PanierAvide panieravide at riseup.net
Sun Jul 24 07:27:46 UTC 2016


In my opinion, adding indoor=yes on every single indoor object doesn't 
make sense, as we know they are indoors because they are inside a 
building area and possibly have some indoor tags like level=*.


Le 24/07/2016 à 00:42, Daniel Koć a écrit :
> We are on the way to render artworks on osm-carto (default map layer 
> on main website), but during testing phase I've found that in Louvre 
> they are tagged not only on the exterior, but also some of them are 
> inside the building (as part of the permanent exposition, I guess).
>
> This made me think if - and how - should we tag such features? Current 
> definition is laconic and does not help in this case ("A tag for 
> public pieces of art"). Should we just add "indoor=yes" (currently 
> 67k+ uses), find new tagging scheme or just introduce a policy which 
> doesn't let tagging them?
>
> It is important for a rendering strategy - we're not able to recognize 
> which are visible outside and which are not and it creates a visual mess:
>
> https://github.com/gravitystorm/openstreetmap-carto/pull/2236#issuecomment-234687333 
>
>


-- 
PanierAvide
Géomaticien & développeur




More information about the Tagging mailing list