[Tagging] Feature Proposal - RFC - PTv2 Improvements wrt Rapid Transit

[Martin Koppenhoefer]

subway entrances and elevators: you suggest to add both tags to the same object, but subway entrances are defined as nodes only while elevators can be mapped as well with a way.

linking stop positions and platforms via relation with a station: if the station is mapped as an area, this shouldn’t be needed, as there’s already a spatial link

“restricting stop_area”: first you say only the following objects and present a list, in the first paragraph below, you also name additional optional objects (turnstiles, ticket purchase), this is not clear.

why are tracks optional for route relations? Isn’t that in contradiction with the generic route relation definition? Shouldn’t this become a different type of relation if it isn’t about an explicit route anymore?

Cheers,
Martin