[Tagging] Fwd: How to map a bin with dog excrement bags dispenser

[José G Moya Y.]

Hi!

What city are you talking about?

In Madrid, "Cacacán" bin is intended to dispose dog excrements only. Also,
some municipalities are discontinuing the bag dispensers since there are
people who takes more bags than needed, even without walking with dogs.

I.E. in terms of environmental agents, the bags dispensed should be used
only to deposit excrements on the same bin. At least that is what my
sister, a local environmental agent near Madrid, told me.

If the bin is intended to dispose excrements only, a "recycle=pet
excrement" (maybe "recycle=biological hazard") node should be used, and no
reference to bags should be used.

El 10/10/2017 16:41, "marc marc" <marc_marc_irc at hotmail.com> escribió:

> Hello,
>
> Le 10. 10. 17 à 15:42, Alejandro Moreno a écrit :
> > In Spain it is common to find litter bins that have attached a dog
> > excrement bags dispenser.
> it look like you have 3 questions in one :)
>
> one easy :
> fee=no <> payment:none=yes
> payment:*=* is useful when you need to add several
> payment but when it is free, you 'll never have
> another payment:* tag.
> so imho free=yes is better
>
> the main question :
> it is a waste_basket or vending_machine ?
> the main function is related to bags.
> the bin is useful only after you get a bag.
> if you don't have a bag, you can not use the dedicated bin.
> therefore the few that I have taged have :
> amenity = vending_machine
> vending = excrement_bags
> bin=yes
>
> one node <> 2 nodes :
> for me, one node is enough/better because the bin is related
> to the vending_machine like a coffee machine with a bin
> where you put coffee cup after use.
> But if you still use 2 nodes, it is no need to move one away.
> it like tagging for rendering and except for a very high zoom,
> the rendering will in any case display only one.
> This brings us back to the previous question: if rendering display only
> one, which one ? if I see a vending machine on the map, I can expect to
> have a trash nearby. by displaying a trash, I have no idea if a vending
> machine exist nearby.
>
> Regards,
> Marc
> _______________________________________________
> Tagging mailing list
> Tagging at openstreetmap.org
> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/tagging/attachments/20171010/eb072af7/attachment.html>