[Tagging] Public Transport v3 — starting RFC

Dave F davefoxfac63 at btinternet.com
Fri Jul 20 20:43:26 UTC 2018


In the UK the are forty relations as site=railway_station with the role 
of 'stop'. Am I correct in think these are redundant in relation to the 
current PT schema?

I asked what stop_areas are for on the OSM forum. Could you clarify? The 
wiki states what they are, but not their usage. Are there any routers 
etc who make use of them? Are they really needed? Why were bike racks or 
toilets included in some?

I'm very glad to see it's proposed to deprecated 'stop_position, 
platform and station'. 'Station', when used on railway-station was 
duplication of data which led to confusion & errors. Unsure about "They 
can be used, but they don't mean anything anymore." If they don't mean 
anything they shouldn't be used & removed. The database shouldn't be 
filled with irrelevant gumpf.

What are stop_area_groups for? It appears they just add further layers 
of confusion. Relations aren't meant to be a 'collection of things'. If 
stop_area can be found by something like an API query call, do they need 
to be in a relation? Will/do routers use them?

Could you clarify what is meant by 'segment' in "Stops (platforms) are 
mandatory for a route relation, and segments are not."

"bus=yes, tram=yes, subway=yes" tags on the Station and Stop objects 
will be duplication & superfluous.

I agree that Stations and Stops should be separate from buildings & 

The last line of 
mentions 'public_transport=station'. which I thought you said was 


On 20/07/2018 14:48, Ilya Zverev wrote:
> Hi folks,
> As you might've noticed, in the past year there has been growing discomfort with the current Public Transport tagging schema. Of course, it brought order to our route relations, but also introduced a lot of redundant concepts. We've seen a couple proposals aiming to fix some of issues, but nothing stuck.
> Please consider this new revision for the PT schema, which addresses most of the issues, while keeping as backward compatible as possible:
> https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Public_Transport_v3
> I'd be happy to hear any suggestions. Next week, I'll be presenting it, among other things, during my talk "What's up with the public transport" at the State of the Map conference.
> Thanks,
> Ilya
> _______________________________________________
> Tagging mailing list
> Tagging at openstreetmap.org
> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

More information about the Tagging mailing list