[Tagging] free_standing_emergency_department, amenity or clinic ?

Nita Rae Sanders cosmicrae at gmail.com
Mon Apr 29 20:47:06 UTC 2019


This concerns the best way to tag a hospital/healthcare facility that
is known as a 'free standing emergency department. It is also called
an offsite emergency department.

I posted the question in help questions at this link …
https://help.openstreetmap.org/questions/68977/how-to-tag-a-free-standing-emergency-department

Since posting that question, I have done some research as to the
extent that these facilities exist in the state of Florida:

There are 44 major/primary hospitals in Florida (not including small
rural statutory facilities)

2 have only the on-site emergency department

28 have the on-site emergency department plus one off-site emergency department

12 have the on-site emergency department plus two off-site emergency departments

2 have the on-site emergency department plus three off-site emergency
departments

for a total of 44 on-site emergency departments plus 58 off-site
emergency departments. It appears this is a growing trend in
healthcare to build an off-site emergency department, instead of
building an entire new hospital.

Does this situation dictate a new high-level attribute value (e.g.
amenity=free_standing_emergency_department) or is it better addressed
via …
amenity=clinic, healthcare=clinic,
clinic=freestanding_emergency_department tag ?

Curious what the viewpoints are on this situation.



More information about the Tagging mailing list