[Tagging] club=scout for similar organisations

[marc marc]

Le 02.02.19 à 13:56, Tom Pfeifer a écrit :
> On 02.02.2019 09:21, s8evq wrote:
>> Thank you for your input. I'm glad there are other examples of youth 
>> organisation that are clearly different from Scouts.
>>
>> Could we agree that club=youth does have a meaningful usage, despite 
>> what the wiki currently states? 
>> https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:club
> 
> A club, being an association between people, is not a geographical entity.

what's the exact meaning and the implication of this ?
yes a club of ppl playing poker is not a geographical entity,
it is possible for club members to come with their hands in their 
pockets with only a deck of cards as material.
it's more like the sport tag.
it's more like an agenda "here ppl 'play poker' at least sometime

But did you mean that club is a secondary tag that must be accompanied 
by a physical tag ?
I don't see why a building containing 2 clubs should have several 
physical tags on the 2 nodes nor what they could be.
how 'll you tag a sport club and a scout club inside a school ?

how is a company more a geographical entity ?
it is only a association between ppl (despite some company are 
one-only-ppl) gathering of employees in a physical area that can also be 
represented by another tag, no ?
I think clubs, ngos, office, and the majority of poi all have
the same characteristic (being the/one current use of this area)

> Thus I prefer tagging the physical entity, which is the club home, with
> amenity=community_centre
> community_centre=youth_centre

1) scouting is realy fair away of a community youth centre
a scout room in a school, in an annex of a church, in a communal park, 
this is really not what I would describe as a community centre

2) a community centre is also the current use of this area,
it's a king a "open club" where you can go if you match the criteria
it may be also imply funded by public funds