[Tagging] Use bbq=yes/no or barbecue_grill=yes/no with campsites?
jmapb at gmx.com
Wed Jul 3 15:17:03 UTC 2019
On 7/2/2019 8:20 AM, marc marc wrote:
> Le 02.07.19 à 13:38, Joseph Eisenberg a écrit :
>> There are two similar property tags that describe the presence of a
>> barbecue (BBQ) grill at another feature such as a campsite or picnic
>> If you check taghistory.raifer.tech it's clear that
>> barbecue_grill=yes/no is older and still slightly more common, but
>> bbq=yes/no is becoming more common in the past 2 years.
>> The similar feature tag is amenity=bbq
>> Is there a reason to pick one of these two tags over the other?
> I like having the same string between the main tag for the device
> and the key for the caracteristic of a site having this device.
> so imho bbq=yes is better
Certainly tagging foo=yes to indicate that amenity=foo exists as part of
another feature is standard practice in many cases (atm, toilets, bar
being the most prominent).
Nonetheless I think bbq=yes is ambiguous. To me, the most natural
interpretation of bbq=* is to indicate whether barbecuing is permitted,
rather than to specify the presence or absence of an on-site bbq apparatus.
Consider the situation brought up in this thread last month:
The question was: how to tag a feature where barbecuing is permitted,
but no fixed bbq grill exists? The best suggestion was
bring_own_bbq=yes. But the combination of bbq=no and bring_own_bbq=yes
seems contradictory. Despite the inconsistent spelling,
barbecue_grill=no + bring_own_bbq=yes makes more sense... slightly more.
I'm afraid the possibilities are complex enough that I'd actually
suggest using a bbq:* namespace, ie:
There's the issue of redefining bbq=yes, which has 219 uses... but those
219 uses are already ambiguous IMO -- the only thing I know for sure is
that barbecuing is permitted there. So I don't actually think this is a
redefinition, just a clarification.
(These subtags could also be used to clarify amenity=bbq, which
according to Joseph Eisenberg at
is already ambiguous on the German version of the wiki, covering both
the grill itself and the area where grilling is allowed.)
More information about the Tagging