[Tagging] New page "Approval status" for "de facto", "in use", "approved" etc
osm at imagico.de
Sun Jul 28 13:37:23 UTC 2019
On Sunday 28 July 2019, Joseph Eisenberg wrote:
> Christoph, do you have any ideas about how we could be more inclusive
> and make it easier for mappers from other countries to create and
> document new tags?
I think emphasizing and reaffirming the fact that the wiki is to
document the de facto use and meaning of tags and openly documenting
and explaining contradictions, ambiguities and regional differences in
tagging rather than hiding them to present a subjectively desired
reality of tagging would be a good approach.
If the wiki documents the de facto use and meaning of tags that would
automatically give different language versions of the documentation
equal standing because all of them aim to document the same thing. If
however the wiki aims to document the supposed meaning of tags there
will inevitably be a struggle for opinion leadership on what this
supposed meaning is to be and this struggle will inevitably be
dominated by the English language.
What i specifically think is not a good idea is intermixing the formal
status of a proposal in the proposal process
('draft', 'proposed', 'voting', 'approved' and 'rejected') with either
objective and verifiable classifications of the actual use of tags and
subjective recommendations if a certain tag should or should not be
> I hoped that by better defining the "de facto" status and defining a
> clear way that a tag can be promoted to this value (which currently
> is honored with a green highlighting, just like "approved"), there
> could be an objective and fair way for "in use" tags to be added to
> Map Features without going through the Proposal process.
I don't think there is a reasonable verifiable way to define a
sub-classification among tags that are widely accepted to be used with
a certain meaning but that have never successfully gone through a
proposal process. If there was a way to do this it would probably be
possible to automatically determine this and show such status in
taginfo (although if that involves the historic development that might
be technically challenging).
More information about the Tagging