[Tagging] Feature Proposal - RFC - Top_up (fifth revision)

[marc marc]

Le 08.05.19 à 18:25, egil a écrit :
> https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Top_up

your proposal seems to be affected by a community division on 2 topics:

- osm should it contain everything that a store sells ? probably not, 
but the limit is difficult to establish (we add the type of fuel sell at 
petrol stations)

- how to fill in a yes/no list. in recent proposals, we see some who 
refuse a collection of value in one tag and promote several tags with 
yes/no and some others who refuse a tag list with yes/no and want to use 
one key with a lot of ";" but for which no schema is currently provided 
to list a no (on the namespace page, some have mentioned the prefixes 
"un" (like unmarked) the -, the no- ! but there is a general logic 
missing... this is perhaps an opportunity to launch a discussion on this 
subject to avoid that many proposals are polluted by the same problem.