[Tagging] Tagging specialized head lice removal salons
pla16021 at gmail.com
Wed Aug 12 22:12:47 UTC 2020
On Wed, 12 Aug 2020 at 22:54, Lisbeth Salander <lisbeths at gmx.us> wrote:
> All good ideas except beauty=*, I'm sorry. That recommendation makes
> sense in most cases, but if head lice was a beauty treatment we wouldn't
> need clinics for detecting head lice in the first place hahaha.
You're saying people with head lice are just as attractive as those without
> healthcare=clinic + healthcare:specialty=head_lice_removal would work,
> but these salons aren't expected to offer medical services.
It's about as close as we have, as I see it. Podiatrists are
+ healthcare:speciality=podiatrist and they remove corns and verrucas.
Your salons are removing unwanted stuff from the other end of the body.
In fact, your salons are removing infectious parasites. I think that
them as clinics.
> Maybe healthcare=head_lice_removal would be more succinct?
You may have more opposition to adding to healthcare than to
healthcare:speciality. But I could well be wrong about that.
> As a bonus, that tag works both on its own and for hairdressers
> (shop=hairdresser + healthcare=head_lice_removal). Map renderers should
> ensure a consistent ruling to decide on an icon,
Actually, that's a negative. If it's a hairdresser offering louse removal
one of the services, wouldn't most people think of it as a hairdresser?
And whichever way you answer that (it's a hairdresser or it's a louse
remover) it's more code that has to be added to ensure correct handling
of two top-level tags on a single object. Having it as one of the "beauty"
treatments offered by the hairdresser doesn't cause any extra problems.
Admittedly, it's more complicated to query if you're in a strange place
and suddenly in need of louse removal...
> but it would simplifygreatly both edits
I think not. I suspect iD authors would be upset at having to special-case
a top-level tag onto shop=hairdresser, whereas adding it to beauty=* in
the wiki ought to mean iD picks it up automatically (if it supports beauty=*
on hairdressers at all).
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Tagging