[Tagging] Feature Proposal - Voting - amenity=clubhouse
nathancase at outlook.com
Wed Apr 21 14:19:05 UTC 2021
Voting has started for amenity=clubhouse (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/clubhouse)
The main concerns raised during the RFC were:
* Lack of distinction from a community centre.
Some may feel that a clubhouse is not distinct from a community centre. However, I fundamentally disagree with this (as did numerous on this list) hence the proposal for its own tag. I have given my reasoning on the discussion page.
* Clubs vs clubhouse.
It was pointed out that some editors and editing tools use "club=" on a whole area, which may include the clubhouse. I think this proposal gives us a way of more clearly defining mapping clubs by allowing us to tag multiple "things" (e.g. clubhouse, pitches, car parks) etc will all belong to a club. However discussion of the merits of different tagging schemes was not part of the proposal.
* There is perhaps some ambiguity with other uses of the word "clubhouse".
It's possible, but there was no widespread indication of this and I think the terminology is fairly clear in British English.
* POI used as a node, not on buildings.
It was pointed out that, in some locales, it is discouraged to merge POIs with buildings. The proposal was updated to reflect this.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Tagging