[Tagging] RFC #2: Lake, pond, and reservoir proposal

[Dave F]

On 03/01/2022 14:33, Volker Schmidt wrote:
> Brian's "riverbank" automated edit has caused a lot of problems, in 
> particular it removed river islands and it perpetuated a large number 
> of riverbank-related errors (by creating new dates for the new data 
> with errors copied from the old data). As the edits were not declared 
> as automatic, there are no reasons to doubt the quality of the data. 
> The error types, at least in my area, are widespread import errors 
> (riverbanks derived from landuse data based on landownership, and not 
> on water-land borders, and falsely connected waterways, that are in 
> reality passing one over the other).

Transferring waterway=riverbank tags to natural=water, water=river would 
not create the errors you're describing..

Cheers
DaveF