[Tagging] Specify "private" - e.g. resident or employee parking lots

[Mateusz Konieczny]

Jan 31, 2022, 00:10 by supaplex at riseup.net:

>
> 1: access=private + private=residents/employees
>
>
fails for access=private vehicle=private foot=private
where each of them has a different flavor of private

applies even for parking: HGV/buses may have different
flavor of private

>  2: access=private +      access:residents/access:employees=yes/designated/... 
>
works, though has possibility for nonsense tagging when
access=private was changed without changing subtags

seems to be the best one even if requires ugly namespacing
as alternatives collapse for trickier cases

> 3: access=private + residents/employees=yes/designated/...
>
fails for access=private vehicle=private foot=private
where each of them has a different flavor of private

all schemes above will be invisible for iD mappers which
use presets
but it is already unable to handle vehicle=* anyway
(I just opened https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/8923
show tags to all users - at least ones not understood by iD)

>  4: access=residents/employees.
>
breaks existing use of access tags, anything
checking for private/no would need to check for
that

really bad idea in my opinion
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/tagging/attachments/20220131/47c1d8cf/attachment.htm>