[Tagging] s oneway=yes applying only to vehicles? ) Or is it applying to traffic on main part of way?

[Marc_marc]

Le 19.03.22 à 13:37, Mateusz Konieczny via Tagging a écrit :
> 1) oneway=yes is typically used on roads
> 2) when oneway=yes is used on roads it applies to vehicles and does not 
> apply
> to pedestrians on sidewalks
> 3) when oneway=yes is used on roads it applies also to cyclists on 
> carriageway (unless overridden by oneway:bicycle=no)

I agree (and also for cycleway:*=lane)

> Questions:
> (1) is oneway=yes on road applying to cyclists travelling on 
> sidewalks/cycleway=track?

this is in my opinion the most consistent with cycleway:*=lane

> (2)
> Is oneway=yes applying to pedestrians when used on ways where no vehicle 
> traffic
> is allowed?
> For example is oneway=yes highway=footway oneway for pedestrians?

it is in my opinion ambiguous, especially when it is applied to 
highway=pedestrian
in my opinion it obviously applies to pedestrians since there is nothing 
else it could apply to
using oneway:foot (even without oneway=* would have the merit of being 
unambiguous

> Is it correct to map oneway hiking trail as
> highway=path + oneway=yes + foot=yes + bicycle=no + ski=no + snowmobile=no
> ?

it will depend on the country (since in some countries path allows e.g. 
mopeds and/or horses)
but yes something like highway=path + oneway=yes seems fine.

> (3) is oneway=yes used in meaning "applies to all vehicles" So would apply
> on main road part, on sidewalks, on attached cycleways if mapped as 
> property of road.
> And highway=tertiary cycleway:both=track oneway=yes would mean
> that attached cycleways are oneway in direction of way.
> 
> Or is it better defined as "applies to main part of the way"
> So would apply to carriageway if used on road
> And highway=tertiary cycleway:both=track oneway=yes would mean
> that attached cycleways can be used in both directions.
> So would apply to pedestrians if used on highway=footway

applies to all vehicles if the highway is able to have vehicles 
(including highway=pedestrian that may have exeptional vehicles).
if not, it applies to the main part of the way /foot, cycle, horse)