[Tagging] shop=gun shop=guns shop=weapons shop=firearms

[Marc_marc]

Le 19.06.23 à 18:25, Mateusz Konieczny via Tagging a écrit :
> I propose (based on info I gathered to)
> - remove claim that shop=guns should be replaced by shop=weapons
> (due to information loss, there are also for example shops selling knives)

or improve the advice to avoid the lost : shop=weapons weapons=guns

> - remove shop=firearms and shop=gun and shop=guns redirects

I see no added value to remove shop=gun redirect.
is there a difference between shop=gun and shop=guns ?
if not, shop=gun should be redirected to shop=guns

> Maybe also create shop=knives page

Does it make sense to create a primary tag for each type of weapon?
I find it very fragmenting, especially as there will inevitably be shops 
selling 2 items with different primary tags, which merits a secondary 
tag and not a shop=guns;knives
> Create shop=firearms page, describing shop=gun and shop=guns as 
> duplicates of it.

if it's a duplicate, we don't need a dedicated page,
a redirect is enough.
but I'm not en english native.

Regards,
Marc