[talk-au] Roadside rest areas tagged as camp sites

[Warin]

Rest Areas ... a summary so far?

_Best tag_ to use is highway=rest_area as this reflects what they 
actually are.


_'Camping_' is limited in most of these due to the hard surfaces, it 
would be better to use a caravan tag where this is 'on the ground 
truth'. A tag to use under rest area looks to be caravan=yes. Personally 
I would be tempted to use a separate node/way with 
tourism=caravan_site.. following the thinking of one feature one OSM 
element.

'Camping' or 'Caravanning' appears to be limited to a maximum stay of 
~24 hours at least by some (for these areas) 
http://thegreynomads.activeboard.com/t60796278/rms-rest-area-clarification/

So this maybe be a usefull tag to include caravan:condition:maxstay=24 
(or caravan_site:condition:maxstay=24).

_HGV_
Where the rest area is intended for hgv use only then using access tags 
would be best? access=no, hgv=yes looks suitable.

----------------
_Rendering_. This is poor for 'Rest Areas' (looks to be showing the name 
only at present) and will be a concern for mappers using the tag. 
Hopefully renders will catch up?

_Numbers_. Probably some ~4,000 of these in Australia. Some of these 
Australian ones are already in OSM, total in OSM world wide is ~10,000. 
Changing the present rest areas from 'camp_site' to rest area might 
result in, say, an addition ~2,000 rest areas in OSM? Not a vast number 
.. but any addition helps let the renders know that these things exist 
in some quantity.


Regarding the various gov listings of rest areas .. not certain of there 
legal use for adding data from them to OSM.
Possibly use them for checking OSM data .. where OSM is missing then I'd 
look for web confirmation and the copyright of that confirmation ... 
possibly look to imagery for more confirmation.
And possibly survey. However I'm not looking at that at this time.

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-au/attachments/20170420/a3a9fb5a/attachment.html>