[OSM-talk-be] Cell Phones Antennas

[Wouter Hamelinck]

Even if I have to admit that I sympathise with Pol's  action, there is
clearly no permission so it is a clear no go. Too bad.

> But again, if I had spotted myself those antennas, the problem is still the
> same ?

Warning: ianal
You can certainly let the data inspire you to find all antennas and
get the coordinates by yourself, but it is hard to believe you did if
the data correspond to the ibpt data until the last digit. And no, if
you have tomorrow a dataset with the digits a bit scrambled it is not
very convincing that you got the coordinates by yourself either.

>> Also noteworthy is that the map on ibpt.be says "Door deze site te
>> gebruiken zijn de gebruikers gebonden door de gebruiksvoorwaarden van
>> Google." / "En utilisant ce site, les utilisateurs sont tenus par les
>> conditions d'utilisation de Google."
>
> So does it changes something ?

According to me Google is irrelevant here. I suppose that only
concerns the Google data (i.e. background map)

I can certainly understand that you went after the data. I also have
some datasets that I "found" somewhere and am not supposed to have.
Use them for yourself if you wish, we won't stop you, but don't put
the work of the whole OSM community in danger by importing them into
OSM.

wouter

-- 
"Wie niet in zichzelf gelooft, komt nergens."
                                        - Thor Heyerdahl