[OSM-talk-be] Rendering of stream "Leie" broken

[Glenn Plas]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

On 28-07-16 20:10, Ruben Maes wrote:
> On donderdag 28 juli 2016 19:34 Glenn Plas wrote:
>> Ik vraag me ook sterk af wat de bedoeling is van de 2de relatie
>> die ook Leie heet waarin enkel de riverbanks steken.
> 
> I believe someone tried to migrate to the natural=water scheme but
> didn't remove the waterway=riverbank.

We should keep waterway=riverbank, and delete relation 2393380
altogether, it contains highway=paths and all sorts of stuff that
doesn't belong there.   There are seperated sections and also admin
boundaries that totally do not belong in a waterway.

I do not see the merit of natural=water scheme at all on a river or a
canal.  It's a waterway.  imho, there is nothing to migrate to.
Unless I seriously missed something, the way to do it is the way (not
the area) is the logical waterway.

> 
>> Als ik straks ga meten hoelang de Leie is adhv. deze data gaat
>> dit niet juist zijn.
> 
> Obviously you should measure the type=waterway relation[2], not the
> type=multipolygon relation[1].

Sure, but what if I want to do it by name only, without tagging scheme
quirks.

There is no need for 2 relations, period.  "There can be... only one!"

Glenn




> 
> [1]
>> https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/1201127
>> 
>> en
> 
> [2]
>> https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/2393380
>> 
>> Er klopt ook nog steeds iets niet in die relaties/ways, als je
>> die links opendoet zie je het zo al.
>> 
>> Glenn
>> 
>> 
>> On 28-07-16 18:00, Ruben Maes wrote:
>>> Hi Frank
>>> 
>>> I've removed the area=no that was tagged on it. I think that
>>> was the cause, I hope it renders again soon.
>>> 
>>> On donderdag 28 juli 2016 17:54 Jakka wrote:
>>>> Hi
>>>> 
>>>> A note that the rendering of riverbank "Leie" between
>>>> Kortrijk and Wervik is gone. In the past I added a lot of
>>>> stuff there and it was good. Had corrected several overlap
>>>> riverbanks en controlled begin to end but I do not know what
>>>> to look after. The "Leie" is a natural border with France Has
>>>> there been a mass update from there ?
>>>> 
>>>> Some one with knowledge can check that?
>>>> 
>>>> https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/646584#map=17/50.82877/3.25798&layers=N
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>
>>>> 
Please feedback what and where was the cause
> 
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________ Talk-be mailing
> list Talk-be at openstreetmap.org 
> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-be
> 

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1
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=+Ps+
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----