[Talk-GB] Ordnance Survey response
davefox at madasafish.com
Thu Jan 14 18:27:04 GMT 2010
Andy Allan wrote:
> On Thu, Jan 14, 2010 at 2:27 PM, Dave F. <davefox at madasafish.com> wrote:
>> "Though custom cartography is the right answer for many applications, it
>> will ﬁnd it difﬁcult to compete with the free, universally-recognised
>> cartography of the OS."
>> Are you saying you want to prevent these releases to protect the likes
>> of OSM?
>> Competition leads to improved services through innovation.
> Ah, but you need to consider this not simply as competition, but as
> state-funded destruction of a competitive market. Tax-payers money
> would be being ploughed into producing raster maps, which are then
> given away well below production cost in order to destroy the
> businesses of other companies and individuals.
Andy, The taxpayers have already paid for it, many times over. I resent
having to pay £7.50 for a map I've already financed to construct.
As I've paid for it, I think it should be given to me free of charge.
If it was a market (I see it a state owned monopoly) it was certainly
not on a level playing field due to the state funding of an army division.
Releasing state owned data to the public should level it out a bit, but
probably not completely.
> Anyone trying to
> compete would be up against the government who aren't trying to cover
> their costs - pretty hard to compete with, and not really a level
> playing field.
First you say it's a competitive market, then you say it's not.
> I'd like to see people concentrating on the freedom of the data -
> especially things like electoral boundaries
1. Isn't that what it's been told to do?
2. Won't that be a "state-funded destruction of a competitive market."?
> - and I'd like to see the
> Ordnance Survey consider ceasing producing finished maps in order to
> open up that whole area to fair competition and innovation.
How would it be fair? They would still have to license the data from one
source - the OS as already occurs with the vast majority of other maps
(A-Z etc) & sat-navs.
If the rasters are traceable then the data can be used in competition,
It'll just take longer than if the raw data was available.
More information about the Talk-GB