[Talk-GB] Adding a further 250, 000 UK roads quickly using a Bot?
eda at waniasset.com
Thu Feb 3 11:51:58 GMT 2011
I think automatically importing the OS data for areas where OSM currently has
little to no coverage - or coverage merely traced from Yahoo imagery - is
a great idea. Many people don't want bots to trample on their 'patch' which they
have carefully surveyed, which is fine. But there is still a huge part of the
country which is very under-mapped. Let's get it complete as soon as possible
using the best data we have. (It is my opinion that the OS data is often of
higher quality than a typical OSM ground survey, although of course multiple
surveys by different people combined with the use of Bing imagery will give the
best possible map.)
I also think that what is good for ITO is good for the map in general - if there
is a need to have a complete map for some government contract or whatever, then
that is a need that exists in the real world.
Lastly, I don't believe that adding data from external sources discourages
contributors. Quite the opposite. It is a blank canvas that puts people off.
The way to bring in contributors is to show a map with a few missing details that
are so tempting to fix 'just one thing'...
Ed Avis <eda at waniasset.com>
More information about the Talk-GB