[Talk-GB] Neighbourhood Planning - data import proposal
lists at mail.atownsend.org.uk
Thu Apr 18 21:38:06 UTC 2013
stephen.peters1 at sky.com wrote:
> Comments please on my proposal to upload new data about Neighbourhood
> Planning Areas in England. This will involve re-using parish and
> electoral ward boundaries across the country.
First, perhaps you could explain the steps that you took to follow the
guidelines on the page:
before carrying out this import:
What is the benefit of having the bunch of nodes that you have so far
uploaded in OSM? Surely nothing exists yet until the "neighbourhoods"
that "https://www.gov.uk/neighbourhood-planning" talks about actually
have a referedum to decide that they exist, and then when that happens
they can add themselves? I don't see how your import helps. For
example, I live in an area that has a parish council - they already do
stuff locally. I'd expect any "neighbourhood planning" malarkey to be
just another funding stream for them in addition to the slice from
council tax - surely there's no need in that case for any extra data in
OSM at all?
Also, how does this "proposal" relate to previous changesets such as
e.g. this one:
More information about the Talk-GB