[Talk-GB] OSM point of interest counts in each district as a proportion of FHRS
Dave F
davefoxfac63 at btinternet.com
Mon Jan 2 10:57:31 UTC 2017
Could you expand & clarify please?
What is an OSM candidate?
For Tendring, are you saying there's more entities in OSM with an FHRS
tag than there are in the FHRS government data?
Why are the results arbitrary?
Cheers
DaveF
On 31/12/2016 10:39, Andrew Hain wrote:
> As an exercise in measuring OSM’s coverage I have crunched the numbers
> in GregRS’s CSV output to calculate the number of OSM candidates in
> each district as a proportion of the number of FHRS entries that the
> program reports. The figures are a bit arbitrary and values over 100%
> are not necessarily wrong. The tool doesn’t cover Northern Ireland.
>
> The list is:
>
> 1 Tendring 135.07%
> 2 Gravesham 117.93%
> 3 Isles of Scilly 117.81%
> 4 Rushcliffe 117.58%
> 5 Blackpool 108.66%
> 6 East Northamptonshire 108.17%
> 7 Wellingborough 107.94%
> 8 Guildford 107.82%
> 9 Erewash 106.40%
> 10 Broxtowe 106.14%
> 11 Argyll and Bute 105.49%
> 12 Islington 104.16%
> 13 Gedling 98.48%
> 14 South Cambridgeshire 97.83%
> 15 Edinburgh 97.60%
> 16 Nottingham 97.45%
> 17 Derbyshire Dales 97.07%
> 18 Cambridge 96.83%
> 19 Allerdale 94.78%
> 20 Wychavon 94.78%
> 21 West Devon 94.47%
> 22 Bath and North East Somerset 93.83%
> 23 Oxford 93.09%
> 24 Aberdeenshire 92.90%
> 25 Ryedale 90.70%
> 26 Mid Devon 89.31%
> 27 Central Bedfordshire 88.97%
> 28 Westminster 87.99%
> 29 South Norfolk 87.13%
> 30 South Lakeland 86.94%
> 31 Amber Valley 86.34%
> 32 Birmingham 85.27%
> 33 Poole 84.66%
> 34 Melton 83.60%
> 35 Lancaster 82.43%
> 36 Southampton 82.31%
> 37 South Ribble 81.76%
> 38 Basingstoke and Deane 81.49%
> 39 Sevenoaks 81.44%
> 40 Staffordshire Moorlands 81.22%
> 41 Camden 81.09%
> 42 South Hams 80.09%
> 43 Copeland 79.87%
> 44 Carlisle 79.84%
> 45 Gateshead 79.72%
> 46 Hart 79.69%
> 47 New Forest 79.65%
> 48 Winchester 79.49%
> 49 High Peak 79.23%
> 50 Eden 78.69%
> 51 South Tyneside 78.59%
> 52 Rutland 78.34%
> 53 Perth and Kinross 77.14%
> 54 Derby 77.05%
> 55 East Cambridgeshire 76.82%
> 56 Shetland Islands 76.34%
> 57 Breckland 76.18%
> 58 North East Derbyshire 76.15%
> 59 Bristol 75.91%
> 60 Huntingdonshire 75.45%
> 61 Rother 75.34%
> 62 Sir Ynys Mon - Isle of Anglesey 75.00%
> 63 Malvern Hills 74.92%
> 64 Chelmsford 74.79%
> 65 Hambleton 74.79%
> 66 St. Albans 74.31%
> 67 Sutton 73.25% (corrected)
> 68 Shropshire 72.57%
> 69 Ashfield 72.34%
> 70 Richmondshire 71.91%
> 71 Lambeth 71.70%
> 72 Sir Ddinbych - Denbighshire 71.52%
> 73 Tewkesbury 71.37%
> 74 Runnymede 71.23%
> 75 Chesterfield 70.80%
> 76 Stratford-on-Avon 70.73%
> 77 Fenland 70.50%
> 78 South Oxfordshire 70.38%
> 79 Uttlesford 70.05%
> 80 York 69.92%
> 81 Exeter 69.82%
> 82 West Berkshire 69.75%
> 83 South Gloucestershire 69.64%
> 84 Cornwall 69.64%
> 85 Bromsgrove 69.37%
> 86 Waverley 69.29%
> 87 Medway 69.28%
> 88 Wokingham 69.19%
> 89 North Dorset 68.99%
> 90 Wyre Forest 68.86%
> 91 Cherwell 68.73%
> 92 Highland 68.55%
> 93 Taunton Deane 68.41%
> 94 Cotswold 68.40%
> 95 Mole Valley 68.32%
> 96 Eastleigh 67.89%
> 97 Selby 67.86%
> 98 West Oxfordshire 67.85%
> 99 St. Edmundsbury 67.69%
> 100 East Hampshire 67.66%
> 101 Test Valley 67.52%
> 102 Chiltern 67.02%
> 103 Weymouth and Portland 66.84%
> 104 Wiltshire 66.35%
> 105 Midlothian 66.10%
> 106 Rugby 66.00%
> 107 Maldon 65.99%
> 108 Na h-Eileanan an Iar 65.84%
> 109 Bedford 65.69%
> 110 East Staffordshire 65.37%
> 111 Leeds 65.30%
> 112 Waltham Forest 65.24%
> 113 City of London 65.10%
> 114 Wakefield 65.03%
> 115 East Hertfordshire 64.90%
> 116 Christchurch 64.74%
> 117 Three Rivers 64.61%
> 118 Northumberland 64.60%
> 119 Darlington 64.55%
> 120 Abertawe - Swansea 64.31%
> 121 Gwynedd - Gwynedd 64.16%
> 122 Reading 64.13%
> 123 Stroud 63.85%
> 124 Suffolk Coastal 63.84%
> 125 East Riding of Yorkshire 63.76%
> 126 North Hertfordshire 63.68%
> 127 Cheshire East 63.65%
> 128 Orkney Islands 63.60%
> 129 Craven 63.60%
> 130 Mid Suffolk 63.25%
> 131 Sheffield 63.22%
> 132 Tamworth 63.13%
> 133 Norwich 62.95%
> 134 Solihull 62.82%
> 135 Warwick 62.75%
> 136 North West Leicestershire 62.67%
> 137 West Dorset 62.61%
> 138 Kensington and Chelsea 62.53%
> 139 Surrey Heath 62.34%
> 140 Vale of White Horse 62.33%
> 141 North Warwickshire 61.97%
> 142 Hammersmith and Fulham 61.87%
> 143 Sandwell 61.83%
> 144 Aylesbury Vale 61.49%
> 145 Torbay 61.41%
> 146 Charnwood 61.31%
> 147 Ipswich 61.26%
> 148 South Staffordshire 61.21%
> 149 Ashford 61.00%
> 150 East Devon 61.00%
> 151 Hinckley and Bosworth 60.94%
> 152 Sir y Fflint - Flintshire 60.85%
> 153 Richmond upon Thames 60.84%
> 154 South Derbyshire 60.81%
> 155 North Somerset 60.70%
> 156 Wandsworth 60.46%
> 157 Sir Fynwy - Monmouthshire 60.30%
> 158 Forest Heath 60.27%
> 159 Great Yarmouth 60.15%
> 160 Isle of Wight 59.95%
> 161 Dacorum 59.91%
> 162 Scarborough 59.80%
> 163 Forest of Dean 59.54%
> 164 Teignbridge 59.22%
> 165 Harborough 58.92%
> 166 Chichester 58.85%
> 167 Redditch 58.82%
> 168 Coventry 58.64%
> 169 Swindon 58.55%
> 170 Newcastle upon Tyne 58.48%
> 171 Worcester 58.28%
> 172 Cheltenham 57.93%
> 173 Broadland 57.70%
> 174 Portsmouth 57.55%
> 175 Stafford 57.44%
> 176 Horsham 57.43%
> 177 West Lothian 57.40%
> 178 Hackney 57.39%
> 179 Halton 57.21%
> 180 Swale 56.91%
> 181 Bolsover 56.56%
> 182 Southwark 56.49%
> 183 North Kesteven 56.06%
> 184 Tower Hamlets 56.02%
> 185 Welwyn Hatfield 55.98%
> 186 Wycombe 55.66%
> 187 Canterbury 55.32%
> 188 Spelthorne 54.89%
> 189 Blaby 54.55%
> 190 Herefordshire 54.15%
> 191 Sedgemoor 54.07%
> 192 Colchester 53.89%
> 193 Reigate and Banstead 53.47%
> 194 Newark and Sherwood 53.38%
> 195 Hertsmere 53.31%
> 196 Lichfield 53.30%
> 197 County Durham 53.03%
> 198 Maidstone 52.81%
> 199 Aberdeen 52.78%
> 200 Milton Keynes 52.67%
> 201 South Northamptonshire 52.40%
> 202 Cheshire West and Chester 52.10%
> 203 Tunbridge Wells 52.10%
> 204 Mendip 52.07%
> 205 Braintree 51.93%
> 206 Harrogate 51.62%
> 207 Bassetlaw 51.60%
> 208 Glasgow 51.49%
> 209 Woking 51.29%
> 210 Babergh 51.14%
> 211 Walsall 51.13%
> 212 Bro Morgannwg - the Vale of Glamorgan 51.00%
> 213 Brent 50.87%
> 214 East Dorset 50.70%
> 215 Epsom and Ewell 50.29%
> 216 Brighton and Hove 49.82%
> 217 North Norfolk 49.77%
> 218 Sir Gaerfyrddin - Carmarthenshire 49.75%
> 219 Stockton-on-Tees 49.68%
> 220 Bournemouth 49.58%
> 221 Kettering 49.55%
> 222 Boston 49.32%
> 223 Conwy - Conwy 49.15%
> 224 Wirral 49.01%
> 225 Haringey 48.84%
> 226 Tonbridge and Malling 48.72%
> 227 Telford and Wrekin 48.71%
> 228 Sefton 48.68%
> 229 King's Lynn and West Norfolk 48.49%
> 230 Powys - Powys 48.38%
> 231 East Lothian 48.31%
> 232 Ribble Valley 48.06%
> 233 Daventry 48.05%
> 234 Newcastle-under-Lyme 47.93%
> 235 Leicester 47.72%
> 236 Shepway 47.59%
> 237 Manchester 47.57%
> 238 Lewisham 47.47%
> 239 Tandridge 47.47%
> 240 Luton 47.42%
> 241 Kirklees 47.39%
> 242 Torridge 46.97%
> 243 Bury 46.75%
> 244 North Devon 46.75%
> 245 Harrow 46.67%
> 246 Rushmoor 46.63%
> 247 Pen-y-bont ar Ogwr - Bridgend 46.38%
> 248 Stockport 46.33%
> 249 Sunderland 46.33%
> 250 Wealden 46.25%
> 251 Purbeck 46.24%
> 252 Stevenage 46.06%
> 253 Caerdydd - Cardiff 46.02%
> 254 Sir Ceredigion - Ceredigion 46.02%
> 255 Barrow-in-Furness 45.89%
> 256 Fareham 45.86%
> 257 Windsor and Maidenhead 45.75%
> 258 Havant 45.44%
> 259 Bromley 45.40%
> 260 Elmbridge 45.30%
> 261 Fylde 45.14%
> 262 West Lindsey 44.72%
> 263 Mansfield 44.69%
> 264 Crawley 44.56%
> 265 East Lindsey 44.54%
> 266 Dartford 44.44%
> 267 Chorley 44.35%
> 268 Rochford 44.12%
> 269 East Dunbartonshire 44.11%
> 270 West Lancashire 43.97%
> 271 Dudley 43.96%
> 272 Broxbourne 43.30%
> 273 South Holland 42.97%
> 274 Barnsley 42.92%
> 275 Oadby and Wigston 42.81%
> 276 Wrecsam - Wrexham 42.59%
> 277 Kingston upon Hull 42.42%
> 278 West Somerset 42.40%
> 279 Bracknell Forest 42.28%
> 280 East Renfrewshire 42.27%
> 281 Castell-nedd Port Talbot - Neath Port Talbot 41.35%
> 282 Wyre 41.27%
> 283 Fife 41.05%
> 284 South Bucks 41.03%
> 285 Casnewydd - Newport 41.00%
> 286 Barnet 40.68%
> 287 Trafford 40.54%
> 288 Lewes 40.52%
> 289 Brentwood 40.52%
> 290 Harlow 40.48%
> 291 Thanet 40.37%
> 292 Greenwich 40.17%
> 293 Arun 40.14%
> 294 Thurrock 40.10%
> 295 Bradford 39.99%
> 296 Gloucester 39.97%
> 297 Angus 39.75%
> 298 South Ayrshire 39.67%
> 299 Barking and Dagenham 39.48%
> 300 Hartlepool 39.46%
> 301 Scottish Borders 39.35%
> 302 North Tyneside 39.28%
> 303 Liverpool 39.23%
> 304 South Kesteven 39.21%
> 305 Mid Sussex 39.16%
> 306 Tameside 38.94%
> 307 Newham 38.93%
> 308 Wolverhampton 38.83%
> 309 Moray 38.45%
> 310 Plymouth 38.39%
> 311 South Lanarkshire 38.33%
> 312 Dover 38.22%
> 313 Epping Forest 38.08%
> 314 Middlesbrough 37.72%
> 315 Lincoln 37.70%
> 316 Caerffili - Caerphilly 37.57%
> 317 Merton 37.08%
> 318 Croydon 37.00%
> 319 South Somerset 36.84%
> 320 Enfield 36.54%
> 321 Ealing 36.48%
> 322 Stoke-on-Trent 36.44%
> 323 Hounslow 36.12%
> 324 North Lanarkshire 35.70%
> 325 Rhondda Cynon Taf - Rhondda Cynon Taf 35.61%
> 326 Kingston upon Thames 35.56% (16/12)
> 327 North Lincolnshire 35.39%
> 328 Dundee 35.01%
> 329 Sir Benfro - Pembrokeshire 34.95%
> 330 Gosport 34.93%
> 331 Hyndburn 34.88%
> 332 Hastings 34.63%
> 333 North East Lincolnshire 34.53%
> 334 Waveney 34.42%
> 335 Northampton 34.34%
> 336 Bexley 34.26%
> 337 Corby 33.71%
> 338 Watford 33.59%
> 339 Preston 33.45%
> 340 Southend-on-Sea 33.26%
> 341 Calderdale 32.53%
> 342 Slough 32.35%
> 343 North Ayrshire 32.06%
> 344 Hillingdon 31.54%
> 345 Nuneaton and Bedworth 31.36%
> 346 Pendle 31.01%
> 347 Falkirk 31.01%
> 348 Redcar and Cleveland 30.91%
> 349 Adur 30.64%
> 350 Rotherham 30.46%
> 351 St. Helens 29.95%
> 352 Warrington 29.91%
> 353 Tor-faen - Torfaen 29.53%
> 354 Blackburn with Darwen 29.37%
> 355 Peterborough 29.15%
> 356 Salford 29.13%
> 357 West Dunbartonshire 29.10%
> 358 Cannock Chase 28.77%
> 359 Knowsley 28.60%
> 360 Redbridge 28.54%
> 361 Merthyr Tudful - Merthyr Tydfil 27.64%
> 362 East Ayrshire 27.62%
> 363 Rochdale 27.18%
> 364 Rossendale 27.16%
> 365 Havering 26.80%
> 366 Worthing 25.83%
> 367 Oldham 25.74%
> 368 Renfrewshire 25.52%
> 369 Bolton 25.21%
> 370 Wigan 25.07%
> 371 Basildon 23.95%
> 372 Clackmannanshire 23.84%
> 373 Inverclyde 22.45%
> 374 Doncaster 21.91%
> 375 Castle Point 19.71%
> 376 Burnley 17.98%
> 377 Eastbourne 16.24%
>
> --
> Andrew
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Talk-GB mailing list
> Talk-GB at openstreetmap.org
> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb
---
This email has been checked for viruses by Avast antivirus software.
https://www.avast.com/antivirus
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-gb/attachments/20170102/12be3c78/attachment-0001.html>
More information about the Talk-GB
mailing list