[Talk-GB] OSM UK address project: tags

[Simon Poole]

Am 22.12.2021 um 14:20 schrieb Mark Goodge:
> ...
> Yes, but that's factually wrong, at least in the UK, and the wiki is 
> wrong here. A city is not necessarily the same as a postal town, and 
> shouldn't be used interchangeably. Doing so adds ambiguity to the data 
> which is both unnecessary and avoidable.
>
> For example, as a data consumer, suppose I wanted to extract a list of 
> all the pubs in Stoke-on-Trent. The most obvious way of doing that is 
> to look for everything that's tagged as amenity=pub and 
> addr:city=Stoke-on-Trent. But, if people are using city as a synonym 
> for post town, that won't just give me pubs in Stoke, it will also 
> give me pubs in all the small towns and villages around Stoke. That 
> would be wrong, and it would be caused by a wrong use of the addr:city 
> tag. Separating the geographic concept of a city from the address 
> concept of a post town avoids that ambiguity.
Sorry but your typical user will enter something like 
"https://nominatim.openstreetmap.org/ui/search.html?q=pubs+in+Stoke-on-Trent" 
and is not going to fiddle around with OSM tags.
>
> More generally, the use of city as a synonym for "urban area" in 
> address databases is very much an Americanism, and doesn't map onto 
> British (and much European) usage where the term "city" has a defined 
> legal meaning. It also doesn't match how the average British user of 
> address data perceives the term "city", or how it's used by postal 
> delivery organisations (including, but not limited to, Royal Mail).
>
> If the point of this project is to collect address data for the UK, 
> then we need to collect the data in the format that a typical British 
> user (and contributor) of the data would use. Otherwise, we're just 
> setting ourselves up for a whole world of pain caused by some data 
> contributors reading the wiki and using OSM-specific tags while others 
> just use the tags which reflect the terminology they would use in 
> everyday life. The best way to avoid that is for the wiki to follow 
> typical UK conventions.

Sorry, but everybody in OSM maps their road classifications to UK ones, 
don't you think it could just make a bit of sense for the UK to map 
their address fields to those that everybody else uses because the UK is 
very very very very late to the game?

And again you are confusing the city in addr:city with the city in 
place=city, and what you display to all those people that supposedly 
will be collecting the data in the UK has absolutely nothing to do with 
the string we use as a key internally in OSM. Naturally  there's nothing 
stopping you from using UK specific address tags, it simply makes just 
as much sense as another well known exit.


-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: OpenPGP_signature
Type: application/pgp-signature
Size: 495 bytes
Desc: OpenPGP digital signature
URL: <http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-gb/attachments/20211222/bace4a3d/attachment-0001.sig>