[Talk-GB] Three Choirs Way

[Andy Townsend]

Hello everyone,

I've done a bit of tidying of the "Three Choirs Way" superrelation 
https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/112661 and have removed some odd 
ways that had got added to it, leaving just the three relations:

  * Relation Three Choirs Way (Gloucester to Hereford) (3149262)
    <https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/3149262>
  * Relation Three Choirs Way (Hereford to Worcester) (3149263)
    <https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/3149263>
  * Relation Three Choirs Way (Worcester to Gloucester) (3149264)
    <https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/3149264>

So far so good, but there are also these shorter relations that claim to 
be the same thing in the same area:

   -6168636 | Three Choirs Way (Gloucester to Kilcot) 06:00
   -6168637 | Three Choirs Way (Kilcot to Woolhope) 07:00
   -6168640 | Three Choirs Way (Woolhope to Withington) 09:00
   -6168639 | Three Choirs Way (Withington to Stanford Bishop)     10:00
   -6168638 | Three Choirs Way (Stanford Bishop to Worcester)     11:00
   -6168641 | Three Choirs Way (Worcester to Malvern) 01:00
   -6088563 | Three Choirs Way (Malvern Hills)                03:00
   -6088565 | Three Choirs Way (Hollybush to Gloucester) 05:00

The "times" on each line above are roughly where they would be on a 
clock face with North at 12:00.

Does anyone know if these shorter relations constitute "official 
sections" (and therefore deserve to stay with the longer duplicates 
removed) or if they are just later-created duplicates of the three 
relations above?

I'm asking here because the original adder of these routes is long gone 
from OSM, and everyone and their dog has had a go at editing them 
since.  I'm guessing I can just delete the 6xxx series of relations 
above (after checking that there are no gaps in the 3xxx series), but 
wanted to make sure first.

Best Regards,

Andy

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-gb/attachments/20211101/6e9b15a7/attachment.htm>