[OSM-talk-ie] An attempt to geocode the list of schools from Dept. Ed. leads nowhere

[Rory McCann]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Hi all,

As as been mentioned on this list, in the UK they are doing a quarterly
project to map more schools[1] and there is a list of schools from the
Department of Education[2][3], but that only has addresses, not location
s.

I thought I'd download that file and throw it at Nominatim and see if we
can't geocode those addresses, and have something to work with. I
thought with all the mapped townlands, that Nominatim might be OK at
some of the rural addresses.

The results are not good.

Nominatim returns a bounding box for a result. Here's what happens when
you try to geocode all the primary schools: http://i.imgur.com/CFEW7Oa.p
ng

The big boxes are where nominatim was only able to get the county. You
can see that many other boxes are just around towns and villages.
Nothing more detailed than that. The map might as well be a map of
"Counties and Towns of Ireland", which is useless for locating schools.

An example address is "SCOIL NAOMH MICHEAL,SNEEM,CO KERRY". It's no
surprise that Nominatim cannot get any more accurate than the village of
Sneem in that case. The other school in Sneem, SCOIL
EOIN,TAHILLA,SNEEM,CO. KERRY, is hardly more accurate.

The code is in the "ie-schools-geocode" repository on our github[4]  Run
"make install primary-schools-areas.shp" to generate the data. The
geocoding is done in "geocode-single.sh"[5].

That image is based on the shapefile in primary-schools-areas.zip[6]. If
you don't want to generate the data, you can just download it directly
from github. By using the Open Data plug-in you can open it in JOSM.

Unfortunately, it looks like the schools list database isn't very useful
for mapping all the schools.

Irish addresses, eh?

- -- 

Rory


[1]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-ie/2016-January/001418.ht
ml
[2]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-ie/2016-January/001424.ht
ml
[3]
https://www.education.ie/en/Publications/Statistics/Data-on-Individual-S
chools/Data-on-Individual-Schools.html
[4] https://github.com/osmie/ie-schools-geocode
[5]
https://github.com/osmie/ie-schools-geocode/blob/master/geocode-single.s
h
[6]
https://github.com/osmie/ie-schools-geocode/blob/master/primary-schools-
areas.zip

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.22 (GNU/Linux)

iQEcBAEBAgAGBQJWsmZOAAoJEOrWdmeZivv2N3EH/2qAh9rn4vpDXX5TzeGonMNE
bRYvwQ/4ahwg8+YKtFlLlypusfeBZxl17C3qec/G2avApF/Gi1O+QgF/sks9oIQI
62IZGcl7xhcbzRBFD08df22qY4OeFlT0lyUELVpo1tfdiPSN0hEWn+H+eIc8I0BH
pmK3qlgoK/jKAbhm/YrfKL4af/UDyPAEccoBDbWkfcjAyJ0PECOXgS4XoTXYZimS
aDC2XUOIMyhEn5BmSznMcViykLdLQng8sMJBndZoXkAUEQE/45Lo+FiuUvrfKUE7
W8nB1SYDbpevH1OGxBuBM99wP3F6CUVkj/V2jB7SlISI+pvYTNJL7hiWL6a1IQg=
=5Txv
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----