[Talk-transit] Proposed Feature - 2nd RFC - Public Transport

[Michał Borsuk]

Am 12.01.2011 00:54, schrieb Vincent Pottier:
> Le 11/01/2011 18:25, Michał Borsuk a écrit :
>>
>>     I totally agree! For me it was a very timeconsuming search when I
>>     tried to figure out how to set the role of an element in the route. I
>>     found contradicting wiki pages 
>>
>>
>> YES! that's the point, and that's been said before. Make the wiki 
>> pages clear, call it "standard", and there you go.
> When a new comer is mapping on JOSM, 
You put "newcomer" and "JOSM" in one sentence?

> with a good interface, 

cough cough. JOSM and good interface? I beg your pardon? You clearly 
forgot your beginnings. JOSM is the essential tol for the advanced user, 
but it's the least friendly (and ugliest) piece of software out of the 
three.

> he has not his eyes in the wiki.
> It is easier for him to manage a one way relation, and an other one 
> way relation.
We are clearly talking about two different things.
>>
>>     an when I found the Oxomoa scheme with
>>     different relations for each direction I thought this is a quite
>>     simple
>>     solution for the confutision.
>>
>>
>> Again, how do you implement it in Potlatch?
> It is an other matter. We don't map for the editors. And Potlatch 
> evolves. JOSM did it.
You didn't answer my question.
>> How about changing the route temporarily? How about Paris RER, which 
>> has several trains with different destinations? Do we produce 12 
>> relations for line X, which has 6 variants? Possible, but crazy.
> OK, the new comer will do maintenance on potlatch for the French RER ?
No, not a newcomer. Let me quote the question again, because you may 
have lost it in the text: /"How about Paris RER, which has several 
trains with different destinations? Do we produce 12 relations for line 
X, which has 6 variants?"
/
How non-time-consuming is this for an advanced user, and how do you 
perform this without installing Java?
/
/
> They are people with more skill, and other tools for that.

You don't get it. The route to become a pro is to be a beginner first. 
But I am not going to repeat what I wrote three times again.



-- 
Best regards, mit freundlichen Grüssen, meilleurs sentiments, Pozdrowienia,

Michał Borsuk

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-transit/attachments/20110112/d08d2dd5/attachment.html>