[Talk-transit] stop_position proposal

Roland Olbricht roland.olbricht at gmx.de
Tue Apr 17 04:57:13 UTC 2018


Dear all,

as a follow-up a statistic about whether highway=bus_stop is rather used 
on-street or off-street. The vast majority is (now) mapping bus stops 
off the street. The numbers vary, 99% of all bus stops in United Kingdom 
are mapped off street, about 80%-90% in France, Italy, and Germany. But 
also only 65% in Poland.

The request is per country, here "United Kingdom" as an example. Please 
change the country to your country of interest:
https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/xXp
The runtime can vary, and for Germany it is several minutes.
The important data points are the first entries on the "Data" tab.
The results visiable on the map indicate which stops the query could not 
sort as either on-the-road or off-the-road (including being on a footway 
or similar) because it could not classify the highway value as footway 
or vehicle related. highway=pedestrian is classified as vehicle way, 
because in all the examples I have checked it has been used that way:
https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/xXq

Maybe we should, rather than blurring the line between on-street and 
off-street use, make off-street the officially preferred way of mapping.

Best regards,
Roland



More information about the Talk-transit mailing list