[Talk-us] TIGER edited map updated with Toby's suggestion

[andrzej zaborowski]

On 25 January 2011 03:36, Mike N <niceman at att.net> wrote:
>> How about changing:
>> - UID must be balrog_kun or DaveHansenTiger
>> to:
>> - (UID=balrog_kun and changeset in list_of_changesets) or
>> UID=DaveHansenTiger
>>
>> where list_of_changesets is the list of changeset IDs that were used for
>> the name expansion.
>
>  This won't work either because balrog_kun may have un-abbreviated a road
> that had previously been edited.

Together with the version check it would work better than the current
heuristic, but only minimally better.

>
>  It currently looks correct, in pseudo code,
>
>  Not Edited = (user:DaveHansenTiger AND (Date between 2007-09-01 and
> 2008-05-04)
> OR  (user:Milenko and (Date between 2008-10-29 and 2007-12-12) )
> OR (user:balrog-kun and version<3)
>
>   I believe that is the correct logic.  The scripts of balrog-kun that I've
> seen only automatically un-abbreviate TIGER ways, so there shouldn't be any
> false positives.

As someone noticed, the scripts did not go too far in checking that
the ways were from TIGER import and affected some 100% user-mapped
areas too (mostly positively though)

Cheers