[OSM-talk] live editing and conflict management

Robert Vollmert rvollmert-lists at gmx.net
Tue Dec 16 09:45:35 GMT 2008


Hi Richard,

please don't mistake me for one of the German Potlatch haters. I  
rather like it, and acknowledge the great work you've done. But:

On Dec 16, 2008, at 10:24, Richard Fairhurst wrote:
> management. Conflict management isn't really an issue when you're
> redownloading from the server every minute or so; it is when you're  
> clicking
> 'Upload' after an hour's editing.

I don't think that's true: It's a problem as soon as two people are  
editing simultaneously in the same area. I ran into the problem a bit  
recently when giving phone support to somebody new to OSM, both  
editing the same area in Potlatch. Mostly, I took care to use "Play"  
mode, but when not, it was quite hard to resist fixing one or the  
other small error.

Another situation where this is quite likely to show up is when two  
people try to fix OpenStreetBugs as soon as they appear.

With API 0.6, we'll notice when this happens, right?

By the way, has anyone successfully disabled the Potlatch welcome  
dialog?

Cheers
Robert





More information about the talk mailing list