[OSM-talk] proposal rejected - climbing_wall

[Robin Paulson]

On 22/01/2008, Rob Reid <rob at robreid.co.nz> wrote:
> Robin Paulson wrote the following on 22/01/2008 07:44:
> > voting has ended on this proposal, with 6 yes votes and 3 no votes
> >
> > http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/index.php/Proposed_features/Climbing_Wall
> >
> > the proposal will be moved from the proposed features page to the
> > rejected features page
> >
> >
> I may be mis-reading the voting rules on the proposed features page but
> how does 6 yes, 3 no constitute a rejection? Does the vote not need
> extending until it gets to 15 votes?

well, technically someone should have sent out an 'extend voting'
e-mail two weeks ago, and extended the voting until today, but no-one
did, so i'm short-cutting in an attempt to reduce the items on the
proposals page. please change it if you want to.

a proposal can be rejected regardless of whether or not it reaches 15
votes - that is the total number needed if some of the votes are no,
for it to be approved by a majority