[OSM-talk] Selecting cycleways

Tobias Knerr osm at tobias-knerr.de
Tue Aug 18 09:05:23 BST 2009


Rahkonen Jukka wrote:
> Cartinus wrote:
>> You'd want to exclude cycleway=opposite as well, because that is just
>> removing the oneway restriction for bicycles.
>
> But isn't it still kind of a cycleway and thus worth making it visible
> on a cyclemap?

I forgot cycleway=opposite in my first reply, but it really isn't a
cycleway. Imo, "cycleway" is a bad choice of key for this, something
like oneway:bicycle=no would be much more appropriate.
Unlike cycleway=opposite_lane and cycleway=opposite_track, there isn't
any road or section of road specifically intended for bicycles, so it
isn't more of a cycleway than any ordinary road.

Of course, a cyclemap should still make sure to visibly indicate whether
an oneway rule applies to bicycles.

Tobias Knerr




More information about the talk mailing list