[OSM-talk] Two XAPI servers return incomplete data

Andre Hinrichs andre.hinrichs at gmx.de
Mon Dec 14 13:55:49 GMT 2009


Hi List!

I've just discovered that two of the three XAPI servers return
incomplete data when trying to get a relation with tag search. The
relation itself, the nodes and the ways are returned but the ways and
nodes are empty with tags or members.

Try the following requests and you should see what I mean:

1.) http://osm.bearstech.com/osmxapi/api/0.6/relation[ref=A 39]
2.) http://xapi.openstreetmap.org/api/0.6/relation[ref=A 39]
3.) http://osmxapi.hypercube.telascience.org/api/0.6/relation[ref=A 39]

While 1.) and 2.) are faulty 3.) is ok.

E.g. for way 33176005 1.) and 2.) return this

> <way id='33176005' user='geltmar' uid='18106' timestamp='2009-04-14T14:55:08Z' version='2' changeset='526806'>
>   </way>

And 3.) returns this:

> <way id='33176005' user='geltmar' uid='18106' timestamp='2009-04-14T14:55:08Z' version='2' changeset='526806'>
>     <nd ref='291197103'/>
>     <nd ref='26615702'/>
>     <tag k='created_by' v='Potlatch 0.10f'/>
>     <tag k='highway' v='motorway'/>
>     <tag k='lanes' v='2'/>
>     <tag k='layer' v='1'/>
>     <tag k='maxspeed' v='100'/>
>     <tag k='oneway' v='yes'/>
>     <tag k='ref' v='A 39'/>
>   </way>

Since two servers are affected I believe this is a software problem.

Could someone with access to the servers please check this?


Regards
Andre






More information about the talk mailing list