[OSM-talk] Upload of relation from JOSM fails

[Erik Lundin]

Hi,

Frederik Ramm skrev:
> I downloaded the relation and saved it to a file. The file had 666 
> lines. Need I say more ;-)?

To get all members you have to open the relation editor and choose to 
retrieve all incomplete members. Doing this gives me a file with 26288 
lines.

> Using my "binary search" technique mentioned above, I found that the 
> relation upload fails as soon as you include way 4258639. It succeeds if 
> that way is removed from the relation (which I now have done).

Thanks! I have now modified my script to find references to non-existent 
ways as well, and this works for the mentioned way.

> After that I tried to analyse what was wrong with way 4258639. Easy: It 
> has been deleted more than a week ago. I'm surprised you were able to 
> download the relation in JOSM; it should have been flagged "incomplete".

Can't help with this, but I'm using the latest JOSM.

Erik