[OSM-talk] Data reconciliation. Removing CT/ODbL declined users.

Anthony osm at inbox.org
Thu Jul 21 15:22:24 BST 2011

I thought we were supposed to only be talking about this stuff on legal-talk.

On Wed, Jul 20, 2011 at 12:49 PM, Richard Weait <richard at weait.com> wrote:
> Dear All,
> The License Working Group takes the position that it is now
> appropriate to begin reconciling the data touched by users who have
> explicitly declined CT/ODbL.  LWG feels that those users who have not
> responded should have a grace period of another week or two.  You can
> find the list of usernames that have declined here.
> http://fred.dev.openstreetmap.org/license/  This page is updated every
> hour.
> As always, map areas that you know well and in small pieces.  At this
> point don't remove non-compliant data unless you are replacing it;
> another mapper may be able to replace it from local knowledge or
> survey.  Bulk edits and or automated edits and or bots to reconcile
> non-compliant data are not welcome without previous, detailed
> discussion on the dev@ and or imports@ lists.  Share your experiences
> to find the most effective workflows for improving OpenStreetMap data
> quality.
> - Check your local mapping area for data that is not completely
> CT/ODbL compliant.  In Potlatch2, choose Options, and check "Show
> license status".  There is also a licensechange plugin for JOSM.
> - Consider sending personal messages before you edit to those who have
> not accepted or those who have declined based on your judgement.  Some
> users have declined and indicated on their user pages that they will
> not reconsider.  We do not wish to send unwelcome or duplicate
> messages.  See also
> http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Asking_users_to_accept_the_ODbL
> - Replace the data of users who have explicitly declined CT/ODbL with
> your own contributions from survey and other acceptable sources.
> - While this initial stage is focused on replacing data touched by
> users who have explicitly declined, you might find data touched by
> users who have not yet responded.  We leave it to your judgement to
> replace that data now or wait another week or two.
> Once you begin replacing data, check on a regular basis whether the
> user in question hasn't changed his/her mind and has accepted CT/ODbL.
> You can look at http://fred.dev.openstreetmap.org/license/, this is
> updated every hour.
> Best regards,
> Richard Weait,
> on behalf of the License Working Group.
> _______________________________________________
> talk mailing list
> talk at openstreetmap.org
> http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

More information about the talk mailing list