[OSM-talk] Wiki translate extension

Andreas Goss andig88 at t-online.de
Thu Jul 24 18:22:39 UTC 2014

> As for improving translation tasks on OSM wiki, how would you feel about
> the Mediawiki Translate extension ?

I'm against any kind of automatic translation tool, which will just 
cause more errors. When I look up a word I'm usually at least presented 
with more than one translation.

Also this seems geared towards 1:1 translations, which in the 
OpenStreetMap Wiki often isn't the reality, because some things are 
different from country to country. Or for example usefull combinations 
or "see also" might be different. Some pages might even be very country 
specific and a short summary for other languages might be enough as long 
as there is a English documentation. Also warnings like "Do not confuse 
with xyz" might only make sense in one language.

What we really need is people actually editing the Wiki in the first 
place and in my opinion the best way to get people to do so would be a 
better editor: https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/VisualEditor

More information about the talk mailing list