[OSM-talk] Failed water proposal reversal

[Tomas Straupis]

>>  My main point is to get back to reservoir/basin being tagged as "landuse"
> why would that be desirable?

  There will always be more than one opinion on which naming of tags
is "better" because there is no "universal best way" (unless it's
"42").
  What I'm striving for is STABILITY for tagging.

  Landuse reservoir/basin/etc was there before the water proposal with
hundreds of thousands objects tagged at the time of proposal and it
still is used on more objects than water proposal. That is the reason
why I suggest to roll back to landuse version and make rules/guards so
that such "water" proposals would not go through without a VERY good
reason in the future.

-- 
Tomas