[Imports] Veneto import feedback
penorman at mac.com
Fri Nov 22 00:25:23 UTC 2013
> there's a link to this file:
> some remarks:
> Probably best to start reviewing the Veneto import in a new thread. I'll
> copy these to a new one
> - it should be amenity=post_office (instead of postoffice).
> - There are freetext "note"s in italian language that repeat the meaning
> of the tags (e.g. "area pertinenza scuola"/ ospedale), IMHO this is not
> - there is landuse=farm but this should be farmland (currently double
> the usage, less ambiguity).
> - there are 6 types of survey points, all translated into the same tag,
> maybe there is room for a subtag?
> - not sure if the fixmes and notes should be in Italian (or whether the
> keys should be note:it, fixme:it when the values are in Italian).
Nothing wrong with italian note/fixme tags in a region where Italian is
spoken. What I find wrong is automatically generated fixme tags,
particularly looking at some of them
- Some are like "Import CTR Veneto. Collegare ways. Integrare con sport=*
e surface*" on leisure=pitch
The lack of sport=* on the import shouldn't be in a fixme. Maybe the
instructions should require that the importer checks all leisure=pitch
and adds sport information, but I routinely tag sports fields without
knowing the surface, and I'll also tag them without knowing the sport.
It's not an error, it's incomplete data.
- Others are like "Import CTR Veneto. Controllare se historic=memorial"
This is an instruction to the importer, but taginfo shows that these
get left on and uploaded.
More information about the Imports