[OSM-newbies] Tagging a Funicular
Blumpsy
blumpsy at yahoo.co.uk
Fri Apr 17 01:56:37 BST 2009
Dear list,
I've had the opportunity to do some mapping in Viseu, Portugal over the
Easter break. The city council has built a funicular
(see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Funicular), which will be inaugurated
shortly.
Permalink:
http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=40.66205&lon=-7.91215&zoom=17&layers=B000FTF
A funicular is essentially a tram/narrow gauge railway which runs on
tracks. Unlike a tram, however, it is not self-powered. The two
carriages are attached to either end of a cable which runs over a big
wheel at the upper station. This wheel is powered by an electric motor.
Half-way up the hill, there is a passing point, otherwise, it's a single
track.
In my particular scenario, the cable is recessed into the pavement,
leaving only a narrow slit through which the car is attached. Otherwise
(with exception of the tracks, which are flush to the road surface),
it's a normal, paved road.
I was unable to find an appropriate tag on Map_Features, so tagged it as
a tram for now. There are also three funiculars in Lisbon, but they are
not in OSM yet, so I could not check how this is done properly.
So here are my questions:
a) Would railway=funicular require a proper feature request with voting
and all, or could we simply sneak it onto the Map_Features page?
b) The street where the funicular runs is rather narrow. Because the
car-cable attachment is through a narrow slot in the pavement, the
funicular does not actually form a physical separation between the two
sides of the road (which is a one-way). In other words: the way for the
road should essentially be in the same place as the one for the
funicular (unlike I've done it now). There are no barriers or
anything--people simply step aside, and cars would have to wait when the
train passes.
So should there be two nearly identical ways, offset by whatever JOSM
allows and the validator accepts? Would the train have to be on a
different layer?
Many thanks for your help
Blumpsy
More information about the newbies
mailing list