[Rebuild] [Talk-cz] czech republic: data wrongly marked as ODbL compatible was Re: Hromadné importy & změna licence
"Petr Morávek [Xificurk]"
xificurk at gmail.com
Mon Apr 2 22:38:16 BST 2012
Pavel Machek wrote:
>> If this is that case, I personally volunteer to help track down your
>> changesets containing the incompatible imports.
>> The only two are the wikipedia imports of places and railway stations,
>> is this correct?
> I think so.
I went through Pavel's changesets and I think I've found all the tainted
data. Here is what I did:
1) I went through Pavel's changesets (except the big ones already
identified as ODbL compatible imports).
2) Counted the number of created or modified nodes that had tags place=*
or railway=station,halt,tram_stop. This gave me 17 changesets that have
at least 10 such nodes.
3) Then I checked them manually and identified the mass imports.
Pavel's tainted changesets incompatible with ODbL+CT:
720911, 720263, 187327, 189654, 188101, 197352, 593595
Special case of changeset 473203: contains mostly import of forests, but
also 12 place nodes from wikipedia,etc., only 3 of them (277999916,
277999934, 277999939) are still in the database. I would suggest we keep
this changeset and remove only those 3 offending nodes when the database
comes from read-only mode.
In the process I've found another changeset with import of places from
wikipedia,geonames,etc. performed by Bilbo. This should be marked for
removal as well:
I would like to thank Pavel for his decision to allow the relicensing of
his work and sincerely apologize for my harsh words in my initial reply.
Petr Morávek aka Xificurk
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Size: 262 bytes
Desc: OpenPGP digital signature
More information about the Rebuild