[Tagging] RFC: historic:civilization and historic:period Re:new key civilization

robert at elsenaar.info robert at elsenaar.info
Thu Jan 13 07:38:55 GMT 2011


Why: fortification_type=hill_fort

Better is: fortification:type=hill_fort

-Robert-

Citeren Johan Jönsson <johan.j at goteborg.cc>:

> Ulf Lamping <ulf.lamping at ...> writes:
>>
>> In practice, lot's of sites have *several* different "roots" throughout
>> the ages.
>>
>> A castle may be build in early medieval ages, continuously extended
>> throughout those ages, largely changed in the baroque era and mostly
>> rebuild after damages of the second world war. Oh, and all of that on
>> top of a hill that was already populated in the celtic age.
>>
>> How do you tag that?
>>
>> Regards, ULFL
>
> I am not used to these fancy namespacing tags, but they look useful.  
>  I guess it
> would be something like this:
>
> -----
> building=yes
> building:architecture=baroque
> historic:castle
> historic:civilization:Celtic, Anglo-Saxon
> historic:civilization:period:bronze age, early medieval, baroque, post-war
> -----
>
> or is it:
> ------
> building=yes
> building:architecture=baroque
> historic:castle
> historic:civilization:Celtic
> historic:civilization:Celtic:period:bronze age
> historic:civilization:Anglo-Saxon
> historic:civilization:Anglo-Saxon:period:early medieval, baroque, post-war
> ------
>
> It is probably the most visible or prominent remains that should be   
> tagged. The
> Celtic hill fort is probably at the most an archaeological site. I guess that
> the archaeological site could be tagged separately, either as a   
> single node or
> as an area. Do not tag if not visible.
> -----
> building=yes
> building:architecture=baroque
> historic:castle
> historic:civilization:Anglo-Saxon
> historic:civilization:period: early medieval, baroque, post-war
>
> historic=archaeological_site
> site_type=fortification
> fortification_type=hill_fort
> historic:civilization:Celtic
> historic:civilization:period:bronze age
> -----
>
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Tagging mailing list
> Tagging at openstreetmap.org
> http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
>





More information about the Tagging mailing list