[Tagging] Conditional Restrictions vs. Extended Conditions

[Eckhart Wörner]

Hi Ronnie,

Am Freitag, 21. September 2012, 17:31:16 schrieb Ronnie Soak:
> Traps? I've found a stray CR tag in the EC file, which I silently corrected.
> And one part of the way was tagged 120 at wet even though it was probably
> meant as without restriction, which I now also changed to be
> symmetrical to the other side.

Fixed, thank you.

> What else do you mean?
> 
> >> Did you want me to upload the result somewhere?
> >
> > If you want to, yeah.
> https://chaos.binaervarianz.de/wp-content/extras/conditional-restrictions.osm
> https://chaos.binaervarianz.de/wp-content/extras/extended-conditions.osm
> 
> Sorry, both files are heavily altered by JOSM.

No problem.
The Extended Conditions version is fine, but you did not solve the Conditional Restrictions version either.
(I will leave the challenge open for other people and send you the solution in a private mail.)

> Oh, ok. I didn't know that. Taking another look at the EC page
> actually reveals a similar case in the examples.
> But an explicit note would be not a bad idea. For the moment, it is
> not defined that multiple conditions are (or should) implicitly
> combined with an AND operation.

Second sentence of the proposal: "A tag with conditions will only have an effect if all conditions are valid."

Eckhart