[Tagging] Added tables for values to key produce
61sundowner at gmail.com
Thu Jan 12 05:17:21 UTC 2017
On 12-Jan-17 03:22 PM, Marc Gemis wrote:
> I thought crop was for farmland, produce for factories in case of
> "natural" products such as dairy related goods. and product for
> factories in case of more man made products such as hifi, cars, etc.
Note the 'ce' on the end of 'produce' compared to the 't' on the end of 'product' ... sorry about how close they are.
Dictionary definition of produce;
Agricultural and other natural products collectively
------------------- As such it includes 'crop' type things. Crops are
not animals .. like beef, fish. But fish and beef are both produce,
hence produce is a wider definition, includes more things. The
difference between produce and product .. is difficult! A product I take
to be something that has been modified from its natural state ..
Crocodile, defiantly a produce, changed to a handbag is, as a handbag,
defiantly a product. Shelled peanuts have had some work on them .. is
that amount of work enough to change them from a produce to a product?
Flip a coin. If the shelled peanuts are sugar coated then they are, to
me, a product.
> On Thu, Jan 12, 2017 at 2:19 AM, Warin <61sundowner at gmail.com> wrote:
>> Following on from landuse=grass .. I have been looking at appropriate tags
>> for those areas used to actually produce grass ... or sod .. or turf as 2
>> other words.
>> From the wiki I first got crop .. which suits. Further searching got produce
>> which also suits. I then looked at the usage - crop wins, and then the
>> values ...product looks much more diverse .. thinking abut it .. produce
>> encompass crops. I think the reason why crops is winning over mappers is the
>> wiki page documentation ..
>> So I have added 3 tables to the wiki produce page; aquaculture, farm and
>> Some of these are present values from both produce and crop usage.
>> I have tried to organise the farm entries into major groups - flowers and
>> beans all together for example. There may be others that can be usefully
>> combined too.
>> See what you think ... these are all additions.
>> Changes to the produce page ...
>> Shop I have added the comment that these sell things .. they don't produce.
>> They may sell farm produce .. but they still don't produce it themselves.
>> I have also tried to make the difference between produce and product clearer
>> .. though the division will all ways be a little fuzzy.
>> On 'my' 'grass' which is where I started .. with the assistance of the GB
>> list, who should have some expertise with UK English, I have decided on
>> 'turf' as the best value .. and to use it under the key 'produce' with
>> landuse=farmland. This leaves the abused 'landuse=grass' alone .. I hope it
>> gets deleted and the appropriate features get move over to landcover=grass.
>> Tagging mailing list
>> Tagging at openstreetmap.org
> Tagging mailing list
> Tagging at openstreetmap.org
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Tagging