[Tagging] Bus relation - circular route - report says not closed

[Georg Feddern]

Am 19.05.2017 um 04:21 schrieb Warin:
>
> P1) JOSM validator reports that the relation is not closed. Yet all 
> elements appear and they are connected.

I cannot verify/reproduce the first part/sentence with JOSM (11639 / 12039).
As the relation editor indeed does verify and show the 'circular' aspect 
of the relation it could anyway be only a validator bug.

> P2) Roles forward/backward are apparently no longer used, and a role 
> to indicate that both directions does not exist. Yet these may assist 
> to have these kinds of roles?

Not necessary - see above. 'Used' direction is always defined by order.

> P3) stop_position ... left side or right side of the way? On a train 
> line this probably works well .. on a road that has traffic in both 
> directions with parking on both sides .. stop_position does not have 
> all that much information.

Yep, thats the way of OSM - the information is in the order of the 
relation and the platforms.

> Thoughts?

Done. ;-)

Georg