[Tagging] Fwd: How to map a bin with dog excrement bags dispenser

[marc marc]

Hello,

Le 10. 10. 17 à 15:42, Alejandro Moreno a écrit :
> In Spain it is common to find litter bins that have attached a dog 
> excrement bags dispenser.
it look like you have 3 questions in one :)

one easy :
fee=no <> payment:none=yes
payment:*=* is useful when you need to add several
payment but when it is free, you 'll never have
another payment:* tag.
so imho free=yes is better

the main question :
it is a waste_basket or vending_machine ?
the main function is related to bags.
the bin is useful only after you get a bag.
if you don't have a bag, you can not use the dedicated bin.
therefore the few that I have taged have :
amenity = vending_machine
vending = excrement_bags
bin=yes

one node <> 2 nodes :
for me, one node is enough/better because the bin is related
to the vending_machine like a coffee machine with a bin
where you put coffee cup after use.
But if you still use 2 nodes, it is no need to move one away.
it like tagging for rendering and except for a very high zoom,
the rendering will in any case display only one.
This brings us back to the previous question: if rendering display only 
one, which one ? if I see a vending machine on the map, I can expect to 
have a trash nearby. by displaying a trash, I have no idea if a vending 
machine exist nearby.

Regards,
Marc